- David Rand - https://blog.davidrand.ca -

No, That is Not Genocide

Posted By David Rand On 2025-06-24 @ 16:32 In | Comments Disabled

Uses & Abuses of the Term “Genocide”

2025-06-24 (Link added 2025-10-12)

The word “genocide” is often employed abusively, for rhetorical effect, and serves mainly to mislead the public, obscure the reality of the situation being described and promote an ideological agenda. Incorrect use of the word “genocide” is semantic inflation which robs it of its impact and trivializes those situations which can legitimately be described as genocidal.

Sommaire en français
Le terme « génocide » est souvent utilisé abusivement, à des fins rhétoriques, et sert principalement à tromper le public, à occulter la réalité de la situation décrite et à promouvoir un programme idéologique. Un usage incorrect du mot « génocide » constitue une inflation sémantique qui lui fausse son sens et banalise des situations légitimement qualifiées de génocidaires.

In recent years, the term “genocide” has been frequently used in many contexts. An examination of the circumstances indicates that the word is often employed abusively, for rhetorical effect, and serves mainly to mislead the public, obscure the reality of the situation being described and promote an ideological agenda.

The United Nations definition of “genocide” [1] can be summed up as killing, harming, preventing births or removing members of a “national, ethnical, racial or religious group” with the intention of bringing about “its physical destruction in whole or in part.”

White Farmers in South Africa

During a meeting with South African president Cyril Ramaphosa in May of 2025, US president Donald Trump famously suggested that white farmers in South Africa (SA) are targets of a genocidal campaign. This is, of course, nonsense. As CNN points out [2], there is a lot of violent crime in SA but out of almost twenty thousand murders in the last nine months of 2024, only 36 involved “farms or smaller agricultural holdings” and many of the victims were black. As the BBC observes [3], no political party in SA, “including those that represent Afrikaners and the white community in general” has made claims of genocide. Evidently, Trump is indulging in his often incendiary language, while pandering to those members of his voter base with racist (anti-Black) tendencies.

The Israel-Gaza Conflict

The situation in Gaza is of course completely different from that in SA, as it involves war. Nevertheless, use of the term “genocide” to describe Israel’s response to the horrific pogrom and hostage-taking undertaken by Hamas on 7th October 2023 is unjustified. The population of the Gaza strip was a little more than two million before that date. According to Wikipedia, the Gaza Health Ministry claims [4] that some 56,000 Palestinians have been killed in the war. Given the partisan source of this information, we can reasonably assume that the true figure is considerably less.

This is not to deny the extreme destruction, privations and hardships endured by the population of Gaza. But it must be remembered that Israel is attempting to retrieve those Israeli hostages still held in Gaza and to destroy the terrorist mafia Hamas which is responsible for this tragedy and which rules Gaza with an iron fist. Most, perhaps all of the Palestinian lives lost could have been saved if Hamas had simply returned the hostages immediately and agreed to a ceasefire.

Israel claims to take many measures to minimize civilian casualties in their efforts to root out Hamas operatives, but that the task is made much more difficult by Hamas’ habit of using human shields [5], placing military installations in or near heavily populated civilian areas, even schools, hospitals or mosques.

Finally, it must not be forgotten that the term “genocide” is indeed relevant to the Israel-Gaza conflict, but in the opposite direction to which it is usually applied. The intent of Hamas and similar fascistic, Islamist parties is the utter destruction of Israel in particular and the Jewish people in general.

The Gaza situation today is analogous to the situation near the end of World War II when the Allies’ goal was to destroy the Nazis once and for all, a process which resulted in a large number of civilian casualties. Should the Allied military command have been accused of genocide for the hundreds of thousands of civilian German deaths which resulted from Allied strategic bombing [6]?

The so-called pro-Palestinian movement in Canada, the USA and several European countries has gone far beyond legitimate criticism of the Israeli government of Benjamin Netanyahu. That movement should be considered “islamogauchiste” (“islamoleftist”) as it has shown itself to be mainly a vehicle for Islamist propaganda. It is insufficiently critical of Hamas. It has greatly increased the presence and intensity of antisemitic activities, masquerading as “antizionism.” The fact that pro-Palestinian demonstrations have on several occasions degenerated into impromptu Islamic street prayers, blocking public thoroughfares without prior permission, is eloquent evidence of the intellectual bankruptcy and religious partisanship of that movement.

Indigenous Residential Schools in Canada

I have written previously about the allegations of genocide in the Canadian residential school system [7] for children of indigenous peoples. The discovery, using ground-penetrating radar [8], of anomalies thought to be mass graves of children near some of those schools led to accusations of genocide directed against that school system. However, to the best of my knowledge, no such graves have been found, at least not so far, years after the fact.

Yet some people, utterly lacking in objectivity, continue to use the word “genocide” to condemn the indigenous residential school system. Such unscrupulous behaviour can be observed, for example, on the platform X where Montreal Gazette journalist Christopher Curtis accused Journal de Montréal columnist Joseph Facal of being a “ghoul” [9] for demanding proof before accepting allegations of genocide.

In the past I have described the indigenous residential school system as a vehicle for “cultural genocide” (as distinct from physical genocide) in light of the fact that one of its purposes was to suppress the languages and cultures of First Nations peoples, often separating children from their families and communities for extended periods. However, I have heard criticism of this expression, in that its meaning can too easily slide in the direction of physical genocide. I think this criticism has some merit. Perhaps an alternative to the expression “cultural genocide” would be preferable.

Trans Persons

Some activists who claim to support the rights of trans persons have indulged in extremist rhetoric, including use of the term “trans genocide [10]” to refer to anti-trans attitudes. In some countries and in some historical eras, trans persons have been or are subject to intense hostility which may turn to violence. However, to apply that expression to the current situation in countries such as Canada or the US, for example, is not only absurd, but in fact hypocritical. Transactivists have openly promoted violence against so-called TERFs (trans-exclusionary radical feminists) who simply point out the incompatibility between women’s rights and the more radical trans demands (such as self-ID and access of trans women to women-only spaces).

The abuse of the term “genocide” by transactivists is a dubious strategy to gain sympathy by analogy with the fight against racism. They have already used a similar strategy to gain sympathy by analogy with gays and lesbians fighting against homophobia. This is ironic, given that extreme transactivists support sex reassignments procedures applied to minor persons, a policy which is implicitly homophobic because the minor in question may simply be a young homosexual erroneously diagnosed with gender dysphoria.

Conclusion

Incorrect use of the word “genocide” is semantic inflation [11] which robs it of its impact and trivializes those situations which can legitimately be described as genocidal. First Nations peoples have indeed been targets of genocidal violence in some situations, but the Canadian indigenous residential school system has not been proven to be one of them. Trans persons can be targets of violence, but that does not legitimize indiscriminate use of the word “genocide.” Frequent misuse of the term is an insult to the memory of those who have indeed been victims of genocide.


Further Reading


Next blog: Le radotage des pourfendeurs de la laïcité [16]

[17] [18]

Article printed from David Rand: https://blog.davidrand.ca

URL to article: https://blog.davidrand.ca/no-that-is-not-genocide/

URLs in this post:

[1] United Nations definition of “genocide”: https://www.un.org/en/genocide-prevention/definition

[2] CNN points out: https://www.cnn.com/2025/05/21/politics/fact-check-white-farmers-south-africa-trump

[3] the BBC observes: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c9wg5pg1xp5o

[4] the Gaza Health Ministry claims: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Gaza_war

[5] Hamas’ habit of using human shields: https://stratcomcoe.org/cuploads/pfiles/hamas_human_shields.pdf

[6] Allied strategic bombing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_bombing_during_World_War_II#Germany

[7] I have written previously about the allegations of genocide in the Canadian residential school system: https://blog.davidrand.ca/pandemic-of-cowardice/#unmarked_graves

[8] ground-penetrating radar: https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/residential-schools

[9] Christopher Curtis accused Journal de Montréal columnist Joseph Facal of being a “ghoul”: https://x.com/titocurtis/status/1841168228816482786

[10] trans genocide: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgender_genocide

[11] semantic inflation: https://k-larevue.com/en/the-meaning-of-genocide/

[12] Quel génocide? Le Hamas et sa propagande ont gagné la bataille de la communication: https://www.ledevoir.com/opinion/chroniques/924468/chronique-quel-genocide?

[13] No, Israel Is Not Committing Genocide in Gaza: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/22/opinion/no-israel-is-not-committing-genocide-in-gaza.html

[14] on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/share/p/19HL5ubKd4/

[15] 10 Questions ‘Genocide in Gaza’ Accusers Cannot Answer: https://x.com/Aizenberg55/status/1957443108397781234

[16] Le radotage des pourfendeurs de la laïcité: https://blog.davidrand.ca/radotage-pourfendeurs-laicite/

[17] : https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.davidrand.ca%2Fno-that-is-not-genocide%2F

[18] : https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=No%2C%20That%20is%20Not%20Genocide&url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.davidrand.ca%2Fno-that-is-not-genocide%2F

Copyright © 2018 David Rand. All rights reserved.