- David Rand - https://blog.davidrand.ca -
The Victimhood Utopia of the Left: How Moralism Killed Politics
Posted By David Rand On 2025-06-03 @ 10:00 In | No Comments
English translation: David Rand
2025-06-03
The left has become obsessed with a binary opposition between dominant and dominated. Claiming to defend the world’s oppressed, it has often supported the most reactionary regimes and movements, in the name of a victim moralism that confuses suffering with virtue.
La gauche est devenue obsédée par une opposition binaire entre dominants et dominés. En prétendant défendre les opprimés du monde, elle a souvent soutenu les régimes et mouvements les plus réactionnaires, au nom d’un moralisme victimaire qui confond la souffrance avec la vertu.
Version originale en français : L’utopie victimaire de la gauche : ou comment le moralisme a tué la politique [1], Charles Rojzman.
For more than seventy years, an ideological constant has run through the Western left: its inability to think of power relations other than through a binary opposition between dominant and dominated. This moral reductionism, inherited from a Marxism devoid of its economic substance and an anti-colonialism that has become an obsession, has led it to a systemic blindness in matters of international politics. Claiming to defend the world’s oppressed, it has often supported the most reactionary regimes and movements, in the name of a victim moralism that confuses suffering with virtue.
The foundational error dates back to the 1950s and 1960s. The left, in an understandable anti-colonial surge after the horrors of empire, embarked upon a path of militant Third Worldism, for which any people in conflict with a Western power automatically became the bearer of a higher justice. This tropism led to a series of historical blind spots: admiration for Maoism during the Cultural Revolution, apology for Castro despite mass imprisonments in Cuba, complicit silence on the Soviet gulags and zealous support for figures such as Ho Chi Minh or Colonel Gaddafi.
But this temptation to substitute morality for politics is much older. Its roots go back to the beginnings of the French Revolution, to the founding rift between Mirabeau and Robespierre. Mirabeau, a figure of lucid reform, intended to fight against privileges and promote greater justice, but without ever denying human reality, necessary balances, or useful compromises. He embodied an enlightened realism, aware that any lasting transformation required respecting the laws of the possible. Robespierre, on the contrary, subordinated everything to an absolute idea of The Good. For him, morality took precedence over facts; ideological purity was worth more than the complexity of reality. He believed in a regenerative virtue imposed at the price of blood and it was in the name of this inflexible virtue that the Terror was instituted.
This logic of the absolute, which sacrifices living men to the idealized man, is found in the current posture of a left which still confuses politics with moral judgment.
Raymond Aron, in 1955, denounced this temptation in his work L’Opium des intellectuels [2]:
“The Western revolutionary loves the Revolution as long as it is distant, theoretical and bloody elsewhere.”
The left was not listening. It preferred self-delusion, throwing itself into the arms of any exotic cause likely to be a vehicle for its revolutionary nostalgia.
As the class struggle faded, a new political anthropology emerged: that of the sacred victim.
As the class struggle faded, a new political anthropology emerged: that of the sacred victim. The revolutionary worker gave way to the structurally “oppressed”—immigrant, racial minority, refugee, colonized or post-colonized people—transformed into an undeniable moral figure.
And this binary vision has not been confined to foreign affairs. In France and other Western countries, it has profoundly influenced the way left-wing elites—particularly intellectuals and media figures—approach problems related to the suburbs, mass immigration and growing insecurity. Any attempt to address these issues based on the facts—rising crime, communitarianism, identity crises—has been dismissed as suspect, even racist. The victim-centered view has paralyzed debate, prevented action and rendered a coherent security or integration policy virtually impossible.
The left, obsessed with the post-colonial, refused to see that the massive influx of populations from former colonies, without control or requirement for assimilation, posed real challenges to national cohesion. It ignored the warning signs. Worse still, it dismissed any identity concerns as a fascist resurgence, when they were often simply the expression of a legitimate attachment to a common culture.
It has thus contributed to making our societies—or at least their educated elites—permeable to all forms of victimhood propaganda, where identity, religious or community demands take precedence over the general interest and republican values.
The historian Marcel Gauchet observed:
“We have changed from a society of responsibility to one of reparation. Complaints have replaced projects.”
…a West obsessed with its own guilt, quick to accuse and deny itself, convinced that its only legitimacy lies in its ability to declare its culpability.
By this logic, any designated victim becomes a mouthpiece for infallible speech. This way of thinking has given rise to what Pascal Bruckner calls La Tyrannie de la pénitence (2006): a West obsessed with its own guilt, quick to accuse and deny itself, convinced that its only legitimacy lies in its ability to declare its culpability.
What makes these ideological errors persistent, even hegemonic, is that the left is not content to be a force of opinion: it is the dominant force in the cultural universe. It holds most of the levers of meaning-making: journalism schools, major media outlets, cultural institutions, universities, publishing houses, the cinema, the performing arts.
Gramsci understood: political victory depends on the conquest of cultural hegemony. It is this domination that explains why the left’s biased analyses of global conflicts—from the Middle East to Venezuela, Africa and Latin America—are so easily echoed in the mainstream media, and why any dissenting voice is immediately suspected of reaction or “imperialist complicity.”
The partisan opinion column, the emotional report, the activism disguised as journalism: everything helps to steer opinion in a single direction. Suffering becomes a display, a performance. Complexity is reduced to slogans. And myths—especially that of “martyred Palestine”—take precedence over analysis.
Nothing illustrates this blindness better than the persistent attitude of the left towards the Palestinian cause. Since the 1970s, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has become a symbolic stage on which the trial of the West is eternally replayed.
The conflict then becomes a permanent spectacle of indignation, ritualised in the media, celebrated in universities and taken up at militant festivals. It is no longer a question of political resolution but of moral purification: Israel must atone, the Palestinians must embody.
Hannah Arendt reminded us that:
“The greatest evil is committed by those who refuse to recognize the complexity of the world.”
But the left no longer thinks in political terms. It dreams. It moralizes. It turns the world into a Manichean theatre where “Good” and “Evil” clash unambiguously. It rejects tragedy, compromise and contingency. It denies the element of force in all diplomacy, the element of ambiguity in all history. It has replaced politics with a form of emotional catechism, in which real people are sacrificed to moral narratives, and where the Good is conflated with suffering that is visible in the media.
In contrast, the conservative right—often considered insensitive to the ideals of social justice—has had the merit of respecting the realities of the world as it is. It has not given in to ideological mirages or sunk into a bloodthirsty utopia. This lucidity, sometimes rough, has preserved it from the destructive impulses produced by political moralism when it detaches itself from reality.
We are at a time when we have to choose between ideological purity and strategic clarity.
Thinking politically means understanding that morality cannot be our only compass. It means admitting that peace is not born of indignation, but of negotiation, compromise and sometimes renunciation. It means refusing to see every victim as a saint, every Western State as an executioner.
The cultural left, through its monopoly on public discourse, has forged a false vision of the world, in which suffering is sacralised and responsibility disqualified.
It has to be said forcefully: the cultural left, through its monopoly on public discourse, has forged a false vision of the world, in which suffering is sacralised and responsibility disqualified. It has elevated weakness to the status of a political criterion. It has imposed repentance as a civilisational project. It has betrayed the heritage of critical reason in favour of a compassionate mystique.
This victimhood utopia produces neither peace nor justice. It produces blindness. It fuels hatred. It encourages fanatics.
If the left wants to become an adult political force once again, it must break with that media and intellectual clergy who turn virtue into a posture and analysis into a sin. It must confront reality with rigour, recognising that freedom is never on the side of those who kill in the name of resentment.
Otherwise, it will not only be in the wrong.
It will be complicit in the chaos which it claims to combat.
Next blog: No, That is Not Genocide [3]
Article printed from David Rand: https://blog.davidrand.ca
URL to article: https://blog.davidrand.ca/rojzman-charles-victimhood-utopia-left/
URLs in this post:
[1] L’utopie victimaire de la gauche : ou comment le moralisme a tué la politique: https://www.facebook.com/share/p/16c9KzddvZ/
[2] L’Opium des intellectuels: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Opium_of_the_Intellectuals
[3] No, That is Not Genocide: https://blog.davidrand.ca/no-that-is-not-genocide/
[4] : https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.davidrand.ca%2Frojzman-charles-victimhood-utopia-left%2F
[5] : https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=The%20Victimhood%20Utopia%20of%20the%20Left%3A%20How%20Moralism%20Killed%20Politics&url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.davidrand.ca%2Frojzman-charles-victimhood-utopia-left%2F
Click here to print.
Copyright © 2018 David Rand. All rights reserved.