- David Rand - https://blog.davidrand.ca -
Two Distinct Types of Conversion Therapy
Posted By David Rand On 2026-05-15 @ 21:25 In | No Comments
2026-05-15, minor revision 2026-05-17
Despite often being lumped together, sexual orientation and gender identity are very different phenomena. The former can be objectively defined, but the latter is a self-perception and cannot. Thus, sexual orientation conversion therapy and gender identity conversion therapy must be considered separately.
Sommaire en français Voici deux phénomènes souvent confondus, mais très distincts : orientation sexuelle et identité de genre. La première peut être définie objectivement, tandis que la seconde relève de la perception personnelle et subjective. Par conséquent, la thérapie de conversion de l’orientation sexuelle et la thérapie de conversion de l’identité de genre doivent être considérées séparément.
One of the most important indicators of the success of the homosexual rights movement is the proliferation of legal measures, in many jurisdictions, to ban sexual orientation conversion therapy, i.e. programs which purport to change a person’s sexual orientation. These pseudoscientific programs are usually promoted by religious institutions motivated by the homophobia of their doctrines, often codified in some ‘sacred’ scripture. For some mysterious reason, no-one is trying to convert heterosexuals into homosexuals. No, they only want to ‘cure’ homosexuals by turning them into ersatz heterosexuals. The success rate, by any reasonable metric, is null. Banning such programs is necessary to protect the public, especially young lesbians and gay men, from religious fanatics who, if allowed to continue, and for no reason other than religious ‘revelation,’ would ruin the lives—or at least the love lives—of their victims.
…we are dealing here with two different meanings of the word ‘sex.’ It may refer to either sexual behaviour (i.e. the sexual act) or sexual identity (a biological attribute).
Over the course of the gay and lesbian rights movement in the late 20th and early 21st centuries, an alliance was formed with trans persons, i.e. those experiencing what has become known as gender dysphoria, a strong, persistent desire to live as a person of the opposite sex. Both gays and lesbians on the one hand, and trans persons on the other, constitute sexual minorities. Thus, an alliance of two such minorities was considered reasonable. Hence was born the famous acronym LGBT, the first three letters representing sexual orientations, the last trans persons. However it should not be forgotten that we are dealing here with two different meanings of the word ‘sex.’ It may refer to either sexual behaviour (i.e. the sexual act) or sexual identity (a biological attribute). Put succinctly, the first three letters refer to behaviour, while the fourth involves the person’s biology.
Gender identity is a self-perception and cannot be observed in any objective way.
Somewhere along the way a slide from ‘sex’ (binary and well-defined) to ‘gender’ (vague and very fluid) occurred and ‘sexual identity’ was replaced by ‘gender identity.’ As a result of the alliance, a simplistic parallel was drawn between sexual orientation and gender identity, using the former as the model, leading to a condemnation of gender identity conversion therapy. This extrapolation to include gender identity is inappropriate, because only sexual orientation can be objectively defined and observed. Gender identity is a self-perception and cannot be observed in any objective way. Unlike sexual orientation, gender identity cannot be associated with any specific behaviour, unless one reverts to antiquated stereotypes of how men and women are ‘supposed’ to behave.
To ban gender identity conversion therapy means banning a procedure whose parameters are very difficult, if not impossible, to define, because the target of that procedure is highly ambiguous to say the least. The idea of ‘converting’ a subjective gender identity into another adds a further layer of ambiguity. There is nothing tangible or objective to convert. How does one go about converting a wish?
A legal ban on gender identity conversion therapy is doubly problematic.
Firstly, it undermines medical care because it prevents medical personnel from giving appropriate guidance in certain situations. As D’Angelo et al. have explained [1], the ban amounts to rejecting any form of therapy other than ‘gender-affirming care,’ forcing acceptance of the patient’s self-diagnosis of gender dysphoria and preventing medical personnel from making their own professional assessment. This is particularly harmful if the patient presents mental health issues other than gender dysphoria, issues which should perhaps be addressed first, before deciding how to manage the dysphoria.
Secondly, such a ban also has negative consequences for everyone’s freedom of expression. Legal measures which stifle public debate of these issues, including speech which may be critical of gender-affirming care, are unacceptable.
To summarize: any law which would prohibit a practice which cannot even be clearly defined—such as gender identity conversion therapy—is a bad law, because it is so open to abuse.
According to the Wikipedia page ‘Legality of conversion therapy [2]’ laws banning conversion therapy have been adopted in several countries in Europe and South America, in several states of the USA and Australia, in Canada and several Canadian provinces, as well as in India and New Zealand. This is excellent news, at least with regard to sexual orientation, and we can only hope that those jurisdictions which have no such ban will eventually adopt one. Unfortunately, the Wikipedia page fails to distinguish clearly between sexual orientation conversion therapy and gender identity conversion therapy. Apparently, the laws adopted in most jurisdictions mentioned include both types.
In the British Isles, a ban on sexual orientation conversion therapy in the Isle of Man came into effect in March of 2024. A few months later, the newly elected Labour government in the UK announced plans to ban conversion therapy [3] in England and Wales, indicating that both types (sexual orientation and gender identity) would be covered by the ban, whereas the previous Conservative government had planned to cover only sexual orientation.
It is as if the gender issue were simply an afterthought, tacked on without adequate consideration of the implications of such an addition.
The explanatory text accompanying a map of the USA, on the website of the think tank Movement Advancement Project, showing which states have conversion therapy laws [4], simply asserts that such laws ban therapies which attempt to change the ‘sexual orientation or gender identity’ of individuals. The site makes little attempt to distinguish the two types. The situation is similar for federal law in Canada (S.C. 2021 [5]), as well as for provincial legislation in Quebec (P-42.2 [6]) and Ontario (Bill 77 [7]). In all three laws, sexual orientation and gender identity are simply lumped together, while in the first two laws, ‘gender expression’ is also included. It is as if the gender issue were simply an afterthought, tacked on without adequate consideration of the implications of such an addition.
In December 2023, the government of Quebec, aware of the difficulties and controversy surrounding the issue of gender identity, announced the establishment of a Comité des sages (committee of experts) [8] with a mandate to study the issue. The committee consisted of two medical professionals and a constitutional lawyer specializing in human rights. In 2024 the committee heard submissions, both written and in person, from a variety of groups and individuals. It released its report [9] in late May 2025.
The committee’s report attempts to please both sides of the acrimonious debate surrounding what has become known as ‘gender ideology.’ It succeeds in pleasing probably no-one. The report acknowledges some of the concerns of critics of that ideology (such as the binarity of biological sex), but is riddled with the tendentious jargon of that ideology (such as ‘non-binary person’). However, a full review of the report is beyond the scope of this article. The focus here is on conversion therapy bans. Did the committee have anything to say about that particular issue?
One of the groups which presented a brief [10] to the Comité des sages was the organization Libres penseurs athées (LPA or Atheist Freethinkers) of which I am president. We did so because we consider gender ideology to be pseudoscience which has no place in the law of the land. Among our various recommendations was the repeal of any ban on gender identity conversion therapy (while of course continuing to ban sexual orientation conversion therapy). One committee member asked whether it would be sufficient to keep the ban but to add an exception for medical personnel. Our response was that that would only solve half the problem, because the ban would still threaten freedom of expression for the public in general. Nevertheless, the fact that the question was even asked indicated that the committee members were well aware of the problem.
…the committee thus recognizes the problem with bans on gender identity conversion therapy.
Furthermore, the committee’s report suggests that guidelines be established ‘to distinguish between rigorous professional assessment as well as the various treatments that could be proposed and conversion therapies which are prohibited by law.’ Again, the committee thus recognizes the problem with bans on gender identity conversion therapy. However, it proposes no specific solution.
…those ideologues insert themselves between doctor and patient to the detriment of both…
Partisans of gender ideology, i.e. those who deny the binarity of biological sex and who put gender identity on a legal par with sexual orientation, claim that they do so in solidarity with trans persons, to defend the rights and well-being of trans persons, to protect them from stigmatization. They are mistaken. By labelling as ‘conversion therapy’ any suggestion that a trans person (i.e. with gender dysphoria) might consider delaying or foregoing sex reassignment, those ideologues insert themselves between doctor and patient to the detriment of both: interfering with the doctor’s ability to offer professional services and depriving the patient of those services when deciding how to deal with his or her gender dysphoria.
…sex reassignment treatments (whether surgical or pharmaceutical) are purely cosmetic and superficial, which is not to say that they are minor or reversible.
In particular, the denial of the sex binary does nothing to help those with gender dysphoria. The most extreme version of this denial is the notion that sex is just a social construct. In that case, the categories ‘male’ and ‘female’ lose all meaning, so what is the point of sex reassignment? A milder form of this denial is to claim that biological sex is bimodal, a spectrum with male and female at opposite ends, with other values in between. In that case, just what specifically are those intermediate ‘sexes’ and how do they relate to any given trans person? At any rate, sex reassignment treatments (whether surgical or pharmaceutical) are purely cosmetic and superficial, which is not to say that they are minor or reversible. If we truly care about the well-being of those with gender dysphoria, then we must ensure that they are well informed of that fact before making any major medical decision.
So-called ‘gender-affirming care’—which basically means accepting without question the diagnosis of gender dysphoria and proceeding with medical treatment for that condition—may itself be considered a form of sexual orientation conversion therapy if applied to minors. Research has shown that a high proportion of adolescents with apparent gender dysphoria, if monitored as they mature into adulthood without transitioning, will become homosexual adults [11] without the dysphoria. As D’Angelo et al. point out [1]:
“…some homophobic families—and, indeed, whole societies—have embraced ‘affirmative’ biomedical trans pathways, as they view a nominally heterosexual trans-identified child as less threatening to their traditional values than a gay boy or lesbian. In cases where the gay child is encouraged to transition, the ‘affirmative’ care is itself a form of gay conversion therapy.”
The pseudoscience of gender ideology is a threat to both women’s rights and homosexual rights, because it erases the sexual dimorphism of humans.
The pseudoscience of gender ideology is a threat to both women’s rights and homosexual rights, because it erases the sexual dimorphism of humans. The fact that some religious institutions oppose gender ideology and sex reassignments for doctrinal reasons does not in any way legitimize that ideology. Gender dysphoria in minors must be handled with great caution. However, to protect human rights, we must affirm every adult’s right of self-determination over his or her own body.
If one opposes sexual orientation conversion therapy then, to be consistent, one must also oppose banning so-called ‘gender identity conversion therapy.’
Next blog: L’insondable mauvaise foi d’une certaine « gauche » [14]
Article printed from David Rand: https://blog.davidrand.ca
URL to article: https://blog.davidrand.ca/two-distinct-types-conversion-therapy/
URLs in this post:
[1] D’Angelo et al. have explained: https://quillette.com/2020/11/01/jack-turbans-dangerous-campaign-to-smear-ethical-psychotherapy-as-anti-trans-conversion-therapy/
[2] Legality of conversion therapy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_conversion_therapy
[3] the newly elected Labour government in the UK announced plans to ban conversion therapy: https://www.bbc.com/news/explainers-56496423
[4] showing which states have conversion therapy laws: https://www.lgbtmap.org/equality-maps/conversion_therapy
[5] S.C. 2021: https://www.canlii.org/en/ca/laws/astat/sc-2021-c-24/latest/sc-2021-c-24.html
[6] P-42.2: https://www.legisquebec.gouv.qc.ca/en/document/cs/p-42.2
[7] Bill 77: https://www.ola.org/en/legislative-business/bills/parliament-41/session-1/bill-77
[8] establishment of a Comité des sages (committee of experts): https://www.quebec.ca/nouvelles/actualites/details/mise-sur-pied-du-comite-de-sages-sur-lidentite-de-genre-52578
[9] released its report: https://www.newswire.ca/fr/news-releases/publication-du-rapport-du-comite-de-sages-sur-l-identite-de-genre-848204378.html
[10] presented a brief: https://www.atheology.ca/briefs/2024-05-21-highlights-comite-des-sages/
[11] will become homosexual adults: http://www.sexologytoday.org/2016/01/do-trans-kids-stay-trans-when-they-grow_99.html
[12] Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity: https://blog.davidrand.ca/sexual-orientation-gender-identity/
[13] The FSU is disappointed that the King’s Speech included a draft bill to ban conversion therapy: https://www.facebook.com/SpeechUnion/posts/pfbid022raJEX1dKAKZcvYsvA41UAS8mjVTVQYpXpB3bE9GSo5ixHYpFqA2NvHv9kR6MmWql
[14] L’insondable mauvaise foi d’une certaine « gauche »: https://blog.davidrand.ca/insondable-mauvaise-foi-certaine-gauche/
[15] : https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.davidrand.ca%2Ftwo-distinct-types-conversion-therapy%2F
[16] : https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Two%20Distinct%20Types%20of%20Conversion%20Therapy&url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.davidrand.ca%2Ftwo-distinct-types-conversion-therapy%2F
Click here to print.
Copyright © 2018 David Rand. All rights reserved.