CFIC Fights to Maintain Religious Privilege

Reply to L. Rosenblood’s Free Inquiry article

2026-04-21

CFIC promotes the maintenance of a major religious privilege—i.e. its symbols must never be banned anywhere—not enjoyed by other ideologies such as political, while simultaneously claiming that religious symbols cannot be defined.

Ce blogue est disponible en français : CFIC lutte pour le maintien du privilège religieux

In a recent article “Quebec’s Bill 21 Fails the Secularism Test” on the website of Free Inquiry, Leslie Rosenblood (LR) of the Centre for Inquiry Canada (CFIC) attempts to convince himself—but fails to convince the reader—that he can be a secularist while simultaneously opposing vanguard secular legislation adopted by the Canadian province of Quebec. According to the introductory note, his article is a response to my text, “Quebec: Vanguard of Secularism in North America,” although he ignores most of my arguments.

Rosenblood’s article lays out a plethora of false and sometimes ludicrous assertions.

LR claims that “Bill 21 infringes on freedom of religion” but he fails to distinguish between religious belief and religious practice. The former is a part of freedom of conscience, as are freedom from religious belief and freedom of apostasy. Religious practice, on the other hand, is part of freedom of expression which may be legitimately limited in specific contexts, such as the workplace, as Bill 21 does. Bill 21 constitutes a modest limitation on religious practice in a specific context and for the greater good, i.e. to protect the freedom of conscience of civil service users and schoolchildren.

LR totally dismisses the issue of proselytism, claiming that there is no “compelling argument that merely observing someone wearing a religion symbol is tantamount to religious coercion.” His use of the word “someone” is particularly misleading. We are not talking about just anyone, but specifically about State agents, employees of the State, on the job, who exercise coercive or moral authority, such as judges, police officers and schoolteachers. The significance of any symbols they may wear is greatly intensified by their authority which is supported by the State.

Why do corporations spend huge sums of money on advertising, promoting their products, logos and symbols? Because such advertising displays work! They do more than merely sell product: they serve to normalize the company’s identity, so that the public will accept its ubiquity. That is precisely why Islamists, for example, promote the presence of the hijab and similar Islamic veils anywhere and everywhere, i.e. in order to normalize their presence. If a person chooses to use their body as a walking billboard for a specific religion by wearing its symbols, that is their right in their private life, off the job. But the State has good reason to object to this for its employees.

LR never considers the effect of proselytism on civil service users and, especially, on schoolchildren. Their freedom of conscience must be given priority over the freedom of religious practice of State employees. That is what Bill 21 does. Consider, for example, the case of a teenage girl from a practicing Muslim family whose parents are pressuring her, against her will, to start wearing the hijab. Now suppose that she arrives at school one morning and finds that her teacher is wearing a hijab. She will in all probability experience this as a form of betrayal. The teacher’s behavior constitutes a lack of professional ethics.

In the absence of compelling evidence that such symbols have no effect, it is reasonable to ban them for State employees in positions of authority, as a precautionary measure.

The burden of proof falls not on the supporters of religious symbol bans but on opponents. In the absence of compelling evidence that such symbols have no effect, it is reasonable to ban them for State employees in positions of authority, as a precautionary measure.

LR claims that Bill 21 violates separation between religion and State. This is obviously false. Bill 21 does precisely the opposite. By banning civil servants from displaying partisan religious symbols while on the job (what they wear off the job is their own business), Bill 21 separates religious practice from the State. LR’s accusation is dishonest.

After falsely accusing Bill 21 of violating the principle of religion-State separation, LR then admits that CFIC’s definition of secularism does not include that principle but amounts to only “government neutrality in matters of religion.” Mere neutrality means that religions may interfere in government affairs, as long as all religions are allowed to do so, and that is indeed what results if civil servants are allowed to wear obvious religious symbols while on the job.

LR is not promoting State religious neutrality. On the contrary, he is promoting State impotence in the face of religious interference.

LR argues that religious neutrality implies that the State cannot define what is and what is not a religious symbol. His assertion is ludicrous. There is no ambiguity about the significance of a crucifix, a hijab, a niqab or a Sikh turban. LR is not promoting State religious neutrality. On the contrary, he is promoting State impotence in the face of religious interference.

LR suggests that there is something morally dubious about Bill 21’s use of the Canadian constitution’s “notwithstanding” clause as protection against judicial challenge. However, that clause is itself part of the constitution, and is well understood as implying that, in case of disagreement between the legislative and judicial branches of government, the former has the final say. Furthermore, LR fails to mention that the constitution, adopted in 1982 by nine of Canada’s ten provinces, was not and has never since been endorsed by the Quebec government. Quebec is legally required to comply with the constitution, and it has done so. But if one wishes to make moral judgements, Quebec has been the victim of an immoral legal maneuver, not the perpetrator.

LR argues that bans are counterproductive and may “backfire and lead to an increase in the proscribed activity.” By such logic, all speed limits on streets and highways should be repealed. We might as well repeal the entire Criminal Code too.

LR never mentions political symbols, so I assume that he has no objection to the State banning civil servants from wearing partisan political symbols on the job, as is the case (and has been for many years) in many jurisdictions including the Canadian federal State and several provinces. For example, in 2017, an Ontario judge was suspended for 30 days for wearing a MAGA hat while presiding in court, but I have heard no outcry about that disciplinary action. If it is impossible to recognize religious symbols, as LR alleges, then how is it possible to recognize political symbols? Furthermore, how is it possible to distinguish between the two categories, religious and political?

To summarize, Leslie Rosenblood, speaking for CFIC, promotes the maintenance of a religious privilege—i.e. its symbols must never be banned anywhere—not enjoyed by other ideologies (such as political) while simultaneously claiming that religious symbols cannot be defined. His inconsistency is blatant. To restore some semblance of consistency, I suggest that CFIC change its name to CRPC, i.e. Centre for Religious Privilege Canada.


Addendum: A Simple Thought Experiment

Let us suppose that a provincial government—say Ontario, or Quebec, or any other—decided that henceforth the main entrance to every government building, every public school, every public university and every public hospital would be decorated with a giant crucifix, two metres high. What would be the general reaction to this decision? Well, for one thing, every secularist, including me, would protest loudly such an egregious display of religious partisanship.

But what would Leslie Rosenblood and the Centre for Inquiry Canada do or say? Since Mr. Rosenblood, speaking as Secular Chair of CFIC, has declared that the State is incapable of determining what is a religious symbol and what is not, how can he or CFIC make such a determination? When challenged, the provincial government could simply affirm that their choice of symbol is purely aesthetic and decorative, with no religious intention. Any objection to their decision could be based only on other considerations such as cost or taste. No secular argument could be made to criticize the decision.

Thank you CFIC for making it impossible to counter aggressive religious intrusion in State affairs.


Next blog: CFIC lutte pour le maintien du privilège religieux

Supreme Court Must Respect Quebec’s Democratic Choice of Bill 21

par Romain Gagnon (Vice President of Sceptiques du Québec), with:
David Rand (President of Atheist Freethinkers),
Daniel Baril (President of Mouvement laïque québécois),
Francois Dugré (Board member of Rassemblement pour la laïcité),
Éric Ouellet (Board member of Droits collectifs Québec),
Michel Virard (President of Association humaniste du Québec),
Andréa Richard (lauréat du Prix Condorcet-Dessaulles)

2026-03-23

When judges, police officers, prosecutors, or teachers exercise authority, they embody the public institution. The appearance of impartiality is an essential precondition for public trust. This is precisely what Bill 21 seeks to preserve.
This is an English translation of an article published (2026-03-15) in Le Devoir under the title La loi 21, un choix démocratique que la Cour suprême devrait respecter.

Sommaire en français Lorsque des juges, policiers, procureurs ou enseignants exercent une autorité, ils incarnent l’institution publique. L’apparence d’impartialité constitue un élément essentiel de la confiance du public. C’est précisément ce que cherche à préserver la loi 21.

Over five days in late March, the Supreme Court of Canada will hear arguments concerning the constitutionality of Quebec’s Act respecting the laicity of the State or Bill 21. More than fifty interveners—a record number for the Court—have been allowed to participate in this case, which involves one of the most controversial subjects in Quebec society: State secularism. Tellingly, the vast majority of those interveners oppose the Bill, despite the fact that it enjoys very broad support in Quebec.

Behind this legal battle, however, lies a more fundamental question: how can a pluralistic society genuinely protect the freedom of conscience of all?

The debate is often presented as one of religious freedom versus State neutrality. This way of framing the issue is misleading. Secularism does not aim to restrict freedom of religion; it aims to ensure freedom of conscience, which is a necessary condition for freedom of religion.

Freedom of conscience means that everyone is free to believe, not to believe, or to change their beliefs. This freedom can fully exist only if the State itself remains neutral with respect to religions. When judges, police officers, prosecutors, or teachers exercise authority, they embody the public institution. In this context, the appearance of impartiality is an essential precondition for public trust.

This is precisely what Bill 21 seeks to preserve. Bill 21 does not threaten religious faith or practice in the private sphere. It merely regulates the exercise of certain functions of authority so that the State is not perceived as endorsing a particular belief.

The history of Quebec sheds light on this choice. For a long time, the confusion between religion and power weighed heavily on public institutions. The Quiet Revolution constituted a significant break: the separation of Church and State, a prerequisite for a freer and more egalitarian public sphere.

One crucial question is often missing from this debate: can a conscience be truly free when it has been shaped from childhood by a belief system that does not tolerate being questioned? Secularism does not claim to resolve spiritual questions; rather, it creates a common framework within which everyone can believe, doubt, or break free from tradition without institutional pressure. In this sense, it protects believers as much as non-believers.

Another voice also deserves to be heard, that of the many women from Muslim backgrounds who have chosen to immigrate to Quebec. Several have publicly explained that they came here not only for economic reasons, but also to live in a society where individual choices—particularly those related to lifestyle, appearance or gender relations—are not dictated by religious norms. Some explain that they removed the veil upon arrival, after having worn it under duress in their country of origin. Their testimonies remind us that secularism cannot be reduced to a mere conflict between tolerance and discrimination. For some women, it is also about emancipation.

The debate surrounding Bill 21 also reveals a deeper divergence between two conceptions of pluralism. In English Canada, multiculturalism has become the dominant principle for managing cultural and religious diversity. This approach does not rely on a strict separation between religion and State; rather, it grants priority to accommodating public expressions of religious identities.

However, the experience of several European countries shows that this model can generate tensions when it fragments the public sphere into distinct communities. Quebec has instead chosen a different path, inspired in part by the French republican model: that of a more pronounced neutrality of public institutions. This approach enjoys very broad support in Quebec, well beyond partisan divides.

If other provinces prefer to maintain the multicultural model, they are free to do so. Quebec is not trying to impose its model on the rest of the country. It asks only that its choice be respected.

The National Assembly adopted Bill 21 and the government invoked the notwithstanding clause so that the Bill could come into effect immediately. This clause, included in the Canadian Charter, allows legislators to exercise a constitutional power explicitly, temporarily asserting parliamentary priority for a democratic choice when fundamental issues affecting the organization of society are at stake.

However, several opponents specifically want to neutralize, or even abolish, this legal instrument. This would amount to depriving Quebec of an essential means of defending its democratic choices.

The issue therefore is not simply legal. It concerns the balance between the protection of individual rights by the courts and the capacity of a democratic society to collectively define certain fundamental rules. To what extent should the courts hold the power to invalidate political choices clearly expressed by a democratic majority?

The Supreme Court justices are obviously not mandated to engage in politics. But they cannot ignore the fact that their decision risks having political repercussions far beyond the current legal debate. If a law supported by a large majority of the Quebec population were struck down by the courts, many would see it as a significant limitation on Quebec’s ability to define for itself the principles that govern its public sphere.


Next blog: CFIC Fights to Maintain Religious Privilege

Quebec: Vanguard of Secularism in North America

Free Inquiry

2026-02-13

The article Quebec: Vanguard of Secularism in North America is published on the website of the American freethought magazine Free Inquiry, published by the Center for Inquiry (CFI) in the USA. A few excerpts from the article are shown below.

Sommaire en français Ce texte, « Le Québec, à l’avant-garde en matière de laïcité en Amérique du Nord » est paru sur le site web de la revue américaine Free Inquiry, une publication du Center for Inquiry (CFI) aux États-Unis. En voici quelques extraits.

[…]

On June 16, 2019, Quebec adopted Bill 21, Loi sur la laïcité de l’État or An Act respecting the laicity of the State. The word “laicity” is a dubious translation from the French “laïcité” and should arguably be replaced by the more familiar English term secularism. Nevertheless, the use of that term in this legislation is a reminder that Quebec takes its cue from France, where secularism necessarily includes the principle of separation between religion and state, not merely religious neutrality. Whereas in the English-speaking world, the separation principle tends to be given only lip service.

[…]

Another law, Bill 9 or An Act respecting the reinforcement of laicity in Québec, was proposed by the Quebec government on November 27. This bill would implement several of the Pelchat-Rousseau Committee’s recommendations. […] Unfortunately, Bill 9 as proposed, Bill 94 as adopted, and Bill 21 as adopted some six years previously, contain no provision to curtail the fiscal privileges currently granted to religious institutions. Furthermore, all three contain a so-called “grandfather” clause that allows an exemption from the religious symbol ban for employees on staff when the law was first proposed. Thus, much remains to be done. Nevertheless, each of these bills constitutes a major step forward.

While Quebec makes steady progress toward secularism, Canada at the federal level stagnates as a soft theocracy (to borrow an expression from Australian secularist Max Wallace). Canada’s head of state is King Charles III, also titular head of the Church of England. The very first line of the Constitution Act of 1982 (which is also the first line of the much-overrated Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms) declares that “Canada is founded upon principles that recognize the supremacy of God and the rule of law.” (Note also the oxymoronic nature of that declaration.)

[…]

Federal Canadian legislation is riddled with religious privileges, probably the most egregious being the religious exception (paragraphs 319(3)b and 319(3.1)), in the Hate Propaganda section of the Criminal Code, which grants immunity to religious speech.

[…]

Support for and opposition to Bill 21 are almost perfectly aligned with linguistic differences. Secularism enjoys overwhelming support from the Quebec population. Secular organizations in Quebec are unanimous in their support. But in Canada outside Quebec, the opposition from politicians and media is ferocious, often expressed in extreme language containing elements of anti-Québécois ethnic bigotry. Nevertheless, even in English Canada, popular opinion does not necessarily agree with the knee-jerk opposition so obvious among political and media elites.

[…]

See also:


Next blog: Supreme Court Must Respect Quebec’s Democratic Choice of Bill 21

Framing the Religious Symbol Debate

The Question is Not IF but Rather WHERE

2025-12-28

Separation between religions and State requires banning religious symbols worn on the job by at least some civil servants and school personnel. Thus, the question for secularists is not whether to ban, but rather where, in what contexts, bans are necessary to protect freedom of conscience.

Sommaire en français La séparation des religions et de l’État nécessite l’interdiction du port de signes religieux au travail par au moins certains fonctionnaires et membres du personnel scolaire. Ainsi, pour les laïques, la question n’est pas de savoir si, oui ou non, il faut interdire, mais plutôt où et dans quels contextes une telle interdiction est nécessaire pour protéger la liberté de conscience.

This article sets forth how the debate about secularism should, in my opinion, be framed, i.e. the context in which the debate should occur. I am thinking in particular of the ban on religious symbols worn by civil servants and teachers while on duty. By “the debate” I do not mean the disagreement between those who support such bans and those who oppose them. No, I mean the disagreement between (1) those who are of the opinion that secularists may agree or disagree with such bans, and (2) those who affirm that secularists must necessarily support such bans, at least in some circumstances, but may differ in the details. It is this latter disagreement which must be addressed by the debate.

If you are familiar with my previous writing about these issues, then you already know that I favour the approach (2) and reject (1). Here, I will explain why it is important to frame the debate in this way.

One of the core principles of secularism is the separation between religions and State, i.e. taking whatever measures are reasonably necessary to prevent religious interference with the affairs of the State, such as legislation, civil services and public education. In order to prevent State employees from engaging in proselytism, whether active or passive, it is necessary (but not sufficient) to ban such employees from wearing political, religious or commercial symbols while on duty. Just as we would not want a judge or schoolteacher to wear a partisan political symbol while on duty, we must have similar objections to conspicuous crucifixes, hijabs or other religious emblems worn on the employee’s person.

Varieties of Proselytism

Proselytism includes a variety of behaviours ranging from directly trying to recruit others to join one’s religion, to imposing one’s religion on others, to simply advertising it. It may occur within a single religion, i.e. the target may be of the same religion as the proselytizer. One obvious example is a pious Muslim trying to convince a less devout Muslim woman that she should wear the veil in order to be a “good” Muslim.

Proselytism…may occur within a single religion, i.e. the target may be of the same religion as the proselytizer.

When the person doing the advertising (or imposing or attempting to convert) is an agent of the State, especially if they are in a position of authority, then that person is using their status and authority to influence others. It is a form of religious interference in State affairs. This is especially serious if the person deals with children who are particularly vulnerable to indoctrination. This is not difficult to understand. It is obvious to anyone who supports the principle of separation between religion and State.

To remove religious symbols while working for the State is a small and reasonable restriction on religious practice—but which has no effect on religious belief. It is a mere inconvenience for the person involved (no matter how loudly they may whine), but has a major benefit for everyone: the absence of religious partisanship and of proselytizing in civil services.

No, We Cannot Agree to Disagree

Thus, if one espouses secularism, one must necessarily accept the notion that banning religious symbols for at least some State employees is the appropriate thing to do. Secularists may disagree on secondary questions. For example, should such bans apply to all civil servants, or only to those who are in regular contact with the public, or only to those in positions of authority? Should sitting members of a legislative assembly be exempted from such bans because they are primarily elected representatives and not considered to be agents of the State?

[…] to oppose all bans on religious symbols in all situations is an extremist, anti-secular position, leaving the door wide open to abuse.

However, to oppose all bans on religious symbols in all situations is an extremist, anti-secular position, leaving the door wide open to abuse. Not only is the principle of separation thus violated, but the freedom of conscience of schoolchildren and civil service users is undermined by allowing school personnel and State employees to advertise their religion (or their political convictions) on the job.

Thus, any person or organization claiming to support secularism but opposing all religious symbol bans is not only anti-secular, but also hypocritical, flagrantly betraying the very secularism they purport to uphold. Neutrality regarding such bans is not a valid option either, because it constitutes a cowardly failure to do the right thing, a failure to protect the freedom of conscience of the citizenry from religious proselytism.

The Urgent Situation in Quebec and Canada

Currently, a legal challenge to Quebec’s Bill 21, which bans religious symbols for some State employees and declares that all persons have a right to secular institutions and public services, is upcoming in the Supreme Court of Canada. The list of organizations and individuals attacking the Bill, some religious but certainly not all, is long and disturbing, indicating just how deep and widespread is the ideological capture of various institutions in our society. Particularly disturbing is the influence which political Islam has already achieved.

If political Islam were not an issue, legislation such as Bill 21 would still be necessary, although less urgent. However, the situation is indeed urgent. All religions are potentially dangerous, while the three Abrahamic religions—Judaism, Christianity and Islam—are particularly toxic. Islam in particular, if applied fully, promotes several brutal practices such as criminalization of apostasy and homosexuality, with severe penalties, as well as the denigration of women. In North America, Muslims represent a small minority while Islamists represent a minority among Muslims, Nevertheless, Islamists have enormous influence in Canada, far beyond what one would expect given their small numbers. The reason for this is obvious: they have many allies among non-Muslims, even among atheists, many of whom have become enthralled by various identitarian ideologies which promote cultural relativism and strongly emphasize personal identities to the detriment of universal human rights.

Accusations of “Islamophobia” function as a de facto prohibition on blasphemy against one particular religion.

A particularly egregious example of this alliance is the Canadian government’s appointment of a “special representative on combatting Islamophobia” whose evident task is to promote religious privileges for Islam. Accusations of “Islamophobia” function as a de facto prohibition on blasphemy against one particular religion. The situation in Europe is worse than in North America, but it is only a matter of time before the influence of political Islam becomes a serious threat to our quality of life.

The non-Muslim allies and facilitators of Islamism remain complacent, wilfully blind to the various strategies of political Islam. The game plan includes promotion of the veil, specious accusations of “Islamophobia” in order to silence critics, proliferation of halal products, playing the victim and the use of the concept of human rights as a weapon against human rights. One example of this last strategy is the use of false accusations of “discrimination” thrown against secular legislation such as Bill 21. Another is the racialization and essentialization of religious affiliation (a process which negates freedom of conscience) in order to denigrate secular legislation with bizarre accusations of “racism.”

Who is Doing the Discrimination?

The accusation that Bill 21 “discriminates” against anyone is patently false. The legislation applies to all persons, regardless of sex, regardless of religious affiliation or lack thereof. To accuse Bill 21 of discrimination (whether against women, or against Muslims or against any other group) is like accusing anti-theft laws of discrimination against thieves, or accusing speed limits of discrimination against owners of fast cars. A person who wears a religious symbol and who refuses to remove it, even at work, even in the civil service or a public school, is either a fanatic or an unwitting agent of fanatics who are using that person to advance their politico-religious agenda. It is misogynistic religions which discriminate against women, while secular legislation does precisely the opposite, discouraging displays of the symbols of such misogyny.

Secularism…must also protect the religious believer from their own community, allowing the individual to set their own course in life […]

I have insisted on religion-State separation as an essential principle of secularism. Another major principle is freedom of conscience. The purpose of the former is to protect the latter. Secularism must of course protect the individual from the undue imposition of other religions or convictions. But it must also protect the religious believer from their own community, allowing the individual to set their own course in life, either as a member of that group, or not, as they choose. Similarly, secularism must protect children from the religion of their family, offering a universalist education and vision of the world, so that each child may chart their own path as they mature into adulthood.

Religious & Political

Allowing teachers or civil servants to advertise their religious affiliation on the job prejudices the teaching and civil service environments, so as to maintain pre-existing communities, pre-existing boundaries, isolating groups from each other in an unhealthy manner. There is no reason to elevate some convictions—the religious—as more important, more essential, more “sacred” than others—such as political ones. Indeed, a religious symbol worn by a civil servant on the job becomes a political symbol in that context.

What we are witnessing here is a vestige of British colonialism […]

Finally, many of the opponents challenging Quebec Bill 21 before the Supreme Court of Canada are from outside Quebec. What we are witnessing here is a vestige of British colonialism, where non-Quebeckers are attempting to interfere in the affairs of a province, indeed a nation, thus flouting Quebec’s autonomy within the Canadian federation. English Canadians who claim to be secularists have a duty to support secular legislation in Quebec, or at the very least refrain from impeding it. Instead, many have thrown Quebec secularists under the bus, by allying themselves with obscurantist religious movements. I will not “agree to disagree” with such duplicity. I condemn it.


Next blog: Quebec: Vanguard of Secularism in North America

The Tedious Conformism of Toula Drimonis

Normalizing the Hijab is Unacceptable

2024-07-31

Journalist and antisecularist Toula Drimonis is at it again. She claims that the image of a hijabi at the entrance to Montreal’s newly renovated city hall is just hunky-dory, with no religious significance! On the contrary, the hijab is loaded with religious and political meaning, regardless of whether the woman wearing it is aware.

Sommaire en français Journaliste et antilaïciste Toula Drimonis récidive ! Elle affirme que l’image d’une femme en hijab à l’entrée de l’hôtel de ville de Montréal, récemment rénové, est géniale et n’a aucune signification religieuse ! Pourtant, le hijab est chargé de sens religieux et politique, que la femme qui le porte en soit consciente ou non.

Ce billet de blogue est disponible en français : Le conformisme lassant de Toula Drimonis

If there were ever any doubt about the vacuity of the words “inclusive” and “diverse” when used by antisecular ideologues, that doubt has been dispelled by Toula Drimonis’ latest diatribe “Montreal City Hall’s inclusive gesture is met with anger,” published 2024-07-25 in the Montreal Gazette. Drimonis’ refuses to recognize the duplicity of the choice of image which welcomes visitors to the newly renovated city hall. After removing the crucifix from council chambers in accordance with Bill 21, the new image displays three persons, of whom one is a hijab clad woman.

But, claims Drimonis, this image is not in council chambers, so it “has no influence whatsoever over city hall and civic governance” and “doesn’t represent religion.” Nonsense. The choice of an image of a hijabi is laden with significance, just as the hijab itself has objective meaning regardless of the intention of the woman wearing it. Drimonis herself admits that the image is in line with the “multicultural and diverse” nature of Montreal, blithely ignoring the fact that multiculturalism is a very tendentious ideology, a euphemism for cultural relativism and multi-tribalism. It is incompatible with universalism which is necessary for human rights. But multiculturalism, supported by buzzwords such as “diversity” and “inclusivity,” is the ideology promoted by both Drimonis and mayor Valérie Plante.

This choice of image is a deliberate affront to secularism and to the Quebec population which enthusiastically supports it. It is a declaration that religious affiliation takes precedence over all other considerations. In particular, religions and their symbols are afforded a level of respect and deference beyond all reason and which would never be granted to political ideologies and symbols.

…the hijab is a banner of political Islam, a symbol of rape culture and the subjugation of women […] a stamp of purity…

Does Drimonis grasp the meaning of the hijab? Of course it is a religious symbol, which is reason enough to avoid it in this context. Any partisan display, religious or political, would be unacceptable. Furthermore, the hijab is a banner of political Islam, a symbol of rape culture and the subjugation of women. The hijab, like all variants of the Islamic veil, is a stamp of purity, indicating that its wearer is a good Muslim woman and, more importantly, that any woman—especially a Muslim woman—who does not wear one is impure and deserves to spend eternity in hell. This meaning is independent of the mentality of the woman wearing it. She may be unaware of that meaning, as Drimonis is, or at least pretends to be.

The Islamic veil is odious. To normalize it is unacceptable. To celebrate it, as city hall and Drimonis do, is obscene. As a society we should be taking steps to discourage the spread of such an extremely misogynistic symbol, especially given that that spread is a deliberate strategy of Islamists.

Civil service symbol bans such as those in Bill 21 are a matter of professional ethics. They are just the sort of measure that is required: banning all religious symbols (thus avoiding discrimination) in certain formal circumstances, i.e. when the bearer is an on-duty civil servant or schoolteacher, but maintaining full freedom in other contexts. But Drimonis fails to distinguish between the civic context where the ban applies and the public but non-civic context (e.g. non-employees going about their private business in public) where it does not.

The basis of secularism is the observation that religion and State make for a very bad combination, and that separating them is necessary to protect human rights, in particular freedom of conscience.

Drimonis is notorious for her opposition to secularism in general and to Quebec Bill 21 in particular. She uses a dishonest ploy which is a common among antisecularists: she claims to support secularism while offering a false definition of that term, robbing it of meaning. In an article published shortly after the law was adopted in 2019, she wrote that “true state secularism has nothing to do with the banning of religious symbols.” Yes it does, in certain circumstances. The basis of secularism is the observation that religion and State make for a very bad combination, and that separating them is necessary to protect human rights, in particular freedom of conscience. That freedom includes both freedom of and freedom from religious belief. Bill 21 recognizes that citizens and schoolchildren have a right to civil services and institutions free from religious proselytism, including the passive proselytism of symbols worn by working staff.

Drimonis would apparently allow religions free rein, as if she considered them to be totally innocuous. Is she unaware that, in Islam for example, apostasy is considered a heinous sin? This tenet is utterly incompatible with freedom of conscience. As for those of us who support separation between religion and State because we see religions as potential threats to human rights, which indeed they are if they gain political influence, Drimonis treats us with contempt, as if our attitude were the unfortunate symptom of a mental illness. She displays similar contempt for the rights of schoolchildren to an education free of ideological proselytism.

In Europe, France is in the vanguard of secularism. That secularism is under threat from religious bigots such as Islamists and pious Catholics, and that threat is made much worse by the support of islamogauchistes such as the political party La France Insoumise (LFI).

Here in North America, Quebec is in the vanguard and secularism is similarly threatened. The objective allies of political Islam here in Canada are tedious conformists like Toula Drimonis who are willing to flout schoolchildren’s rights, just so they can claim, self-righteously, that they are defending “stigmatized” religious minorities when in reality they are facilitating religious fanatics. The most fanatical are men whose aim is to normalize the veil and make it practically mandatory for Muslim women. The aim of the hijab is to stigmatize Muslim women who do not wear it.


Next blog: Les critiques de la cérémonie d’ouverture des Jeux Olympiques se trompent de cible

A Pandemic of Cowardice

2024-05-14

Defamatory accusations of bigotry are systematically used by promoters of gender theory, neoracism (which falsely claims to be antiracist) and anti-secularism. These three movements reject Enlightenment values such as universalism and objectivity, and use social censorship to silence dissent and debate. This behaviour is illustrated using several examples: the false assertion that sex is a spectrum, the Roland Fryer case, the suicide of Richard Bilkszto, the unmarked graves fiasco, and opposition to Quebec Bill 21. The solution to this conundrum is straightforward, but not easy: courage! We must not allow anti-Enlightenment ideologues to silence criticism and debate.

Sommaire en français Des accusations diffamatoires (de transphobie, de racisme, de xénophobie, etc.) sont systématiquement lancées par les promoteurs de la théorie du genre, du néoracisme (qui se prétend faussement antiraciste) et de l’anti-laïcité. Ces trois mouvances rejettent les valeurs des Lumières telles que l’universalisme et l’objectivité, et utilisent la censure sociale pour faire taire la dissidence et le débat. Ce comportement est illustré par plusieurs exemples : la négation de la binarité du sexe, l’affaire Roland Fryer, le suicide de Richard Bilkszto, le fiasco des tombes près des pensionnats pour autochtones et l’opposition à la Loi sur la laïcité de l’État au Québec. La solution à cette problématique est simple, mais pas facile : du courage ! Nous ne devons pas permettre aux idéologues anti-Lumières de faire taire les critiques et les débats.

We all know (or at least we did, before various institutions started succumbing to ideological capture) that sex is a binary biological phenomenon, defined by the type of gamete (sperm or ovum) which the individual can produce. Male and female are the only sexes. Even rare “intersex” individuals represent a combination of the two sexes, not some intermediate sex. The binarity of sex is not an opinion. It is a scientific fact, just as the evolution of species and the spheroidal shape of the Earth are scientific facts.

And yet, it has become fashionable to assert the falsehood that sex is on a continuum, a spectrum. This fashion has even spread to the sciences. In 2023, the American Anthropology Association (AAA) and Canadian Anthropology Association (CASCA) issued a joint statement denouncing “transphobia in anthropology.” In 2019, Scientific American published a blog claiming that binary sex is “phoney science” whose purpose is to “justify transphobia.”

The binarity of sex is not an opinion. It is a scientific fact…

How and why has this occurred? The accusations of transphobia made in both examples reveal clearly what is going on: emotional blackmail. If one fails to conform to currently fashionable gender ideology, then one is a bad, bigoted person. Forget scientific fact. The hurt feelings of a few fanatics take priority. Never mind the fact that “gender affirming care” is just a euphemism for mastectomy or castration (chemical or surgical).

Just as we must respect each adult’s right to self-determination of their own body, we must protect children and adolescents from unnecessary, irreversible, dubious medical interventions.

Neoracism

A similar fanaticism has infected the ostensibly “antiracist” movement, which has increasingly become little more than a cult. I call that movement neoracism. Neoracists are obsessed with so-called “whiteness” because of their hostility to Europeanness.

Classical European racism and 21st century neoracism differ in that the former considers European civilization to be superior to all others, whereas the latter considers it to be morally inferior to all others. They are flip sides of each other. Both are equally racist and Eurocentric. Both are equally irrational, toxic and reprehensible.

I offer three striking examples to illustrate the follies of neoracism.

The Roland Fryer Case

Roland G. Fryer Jr. is an economics professor and, in 2007, at age 30, the youngest black American to receive tenure at Harvard. One of his major research interests is the empirical study of race. In 2016, Fryer published a paper in the Journal of Political Economy in which he concluded that “blacks and Hispanics are more than fifty percent more likely to experience some form of force in interactions with police.” However, he also found that, in the most extreme cases, i.e. shootings, there are “no racial differences in either the raw data or when contextual factors are taken into account.” He suggested a possible explanation: the potentially heavy cost, legal and psychological, incurred by police officers if using lethal force. But neoracists were not buying it. According to neoracist dogma, anti-black racism is ubiquitous and cannot not exist, so Fryer’s finding of no racism in police shootings was heresy.

According to neoracist dogma, anti-black racism is ubiquitous and cannot not exist…

In March 2018, Fryer was accused of sexual harassment, although the allegations involved only verbal behaviour, i.e. inappropriate jokes. He was barred from his research laboratory and, in July 2019, was suspended from the Harvard faculty for two years without pay. One of the members of the disciplinary panel which judged Fryer was the notorious Claudine Gay, dean at the time. Gay later became president of Harvard, but resigned after only 6 months, under accusations of failure to deal adequately with antisemitism on campus and of repeated plagiarism in her (not very numerous) publications.

Gay’s appointment to the Harvard presidency was a result of the demise of meritocracy in higher education. Furthermore, the charges against Fryer were apparently a result of ideological bias, i.e. because Fryer’s objectivity was incompatible with the neoracist ideology which undermined that meritocracy in the first place. In the words of Glenn Loury, “She defenestrated Roland Fryer. She tried to destroy him… by the time she was through with him, he was suspended, his lab was closed, his teaching was supervised, and he was treated like a sex criminal.”

Diversity, Inclusion, Equity

In 2021, Richard Bilkszto attended DIE (Diversity, Inclusion, Equity) training sessions imposed by the Toronto District School Board (TDSB). When the trainer, Kike Ojo-Thompson of the KOJO Institute, asserted that anti-black racism is worse in Canada than in the USA, Bilkszto, who himself had experience in antiracist activism, expressed disagreement. In response, Ojo-Thompson insinuated that Bilkszto was motivated by white supremacism. Ojo-Thompson is evidently the sort of trainer who brooks no dissent and who imposes the Kendian view that anyone who is not actively antiracist must be complicit with racism.

The situation degenerated from there, with Bilkszto taking mental health leave, the TDSB then refusing to reinstate him to the position he held prior to taking leave, then Bilkszto suing the TDSB, which subsequently sued the KOJO Institute. Bilkszto concluded that his reputation had been destroyed and, tragically, he committed suicide in 2023.

Unmarked Graves

In 2021, the possible presence of unmarked graves was detected using ground-penetrating radar near several former indigenous residential schools in Canada. These schools had already been recognized as vehicles of cultural genocide, as one of their purposes was to suppress the languages and cultures of First Nations peoples, often separating children from their families and communities for extended periods. But now, with the possible discovery of children’s graves, the spectre of real physical genocide was raised. Speculation about unspeakable atrocities committed in the name of Canada circulated internationally. As the administration of these schools had been delegated to various churches, especially Catholic, there was a rash of arson and vandalism targeting Christian churches, some of which had been in use by First Nations peoples themselves.

However, as I write these lines, years later, no graves of children from indigenous residential schools have been found. Some sites have not been excavated. At those that have been, only previously marked graves associated with known cemeteries have been found. Thus the entire sensational story has turned out to be null and void, so far at least. And yet, mainstream media continue to repeat the allegations, as if physical genocide had indeed occurred. Already, in July of 2021 the Canadian Historical Association (CHA) published a statement asserting the “genocidal intent” of official Canadian policy. A group of some sixty dissident historians published an open letter, shortly thereafter, rejecting the CHA’s allegations.

…the more serious the accusation, the greater the accusers perceive their own virtue to be. In other words, they do it out of conceit.

Why do some people insist on promoting the worst possible interpretation of historical events, even when the evidence is lacking? Here is one obvious reason: the more serious the accusation, the greater the accusers perceive their own virtue to be. In other words, they do it out of conceit. In October 2023, I had personal experience of this fanatical disregard for objectivity. I was expelled from a Facebook group for Canadian secularists for the sin of posting about this issue. Just before my expulsion, one “antiracist,” true to form, claimed that my posting was “racist.”

Secularism and Quebec Bill 21

In June of 2019, Quebec adopted its secularism law, Loi sur la laïcité de l’État or Bill 21, which bans some civil servants, as well as public school teachers, from wearing religious symbols while on the job. This is a positive measure, although rather weak and should be extended to the entire civil service as well as to all physical installations. If civil servants and teachers are allowed to wear religious symbols while on duty, then separation between religion and State is obviously violated. And yet, very few Canadian secular organizations outside Quebec have expressed support for Bill 21, and some have even opposed it.

Banning the wearing of religious symbols […] targets behaviour, not people.

Some dishonestly accuse Bill 21 of “racism,” but that is clearly a category error. The law deals with religion and secularism and has nothing to do with race. Even more dishonestly, some accuse it of discrimination. But that is clearly false, because it applies to all religions equally. Banning the wearing of religious symbols—which can of course be removed while on the job—is a disciplinary measure (like hygiene standards, for example, or uniforms), not a discriminatory one. The ban targets behaviour, not people.

Civils servants in Quebec and many other jurisdictions—even the federal government of Canada—are required to behave with political neutrality, yet no-one objects to such a requirement. There is absolutely no reason why the expression of religious convictions by civil servants should be allowed greater latitude than expression of political opinions.

The Common Thread: Social Censorship

These three issues— gender theory, neoracism and anti-secularism—are linked by a common ideology which rejects universalism and objectivity. This anti-Enlightenment ideology elevates personal identity and feelings to a level that is unreasonable and does real harm to real people, including the very members of the minorities that that ideology claims to protect. In all three cases, there is a common strategy of social censorship, i.e. using intimidation to silence debate and dissent, using threats of ostracism—loss of job, loss of friends, loss of reputation, loss of contracts, etc.—in order to silence any opposition.

We all know the chorus here: specious and defamatory accusations of transphobia, racism, “Islamophobia,” xenophobia, etc. Any criticism of or disagreement with the ideology is instantly dismissed with accusations of being “right-wing” or “far right.” And it works, because people fear such accusations. It is because of widespread cowardice that the fanatics of gender theory, neoracism and anti-secularism are able to continue doing the damage they do.

To make matters worse, neoracist dogma has greatly strengthened anti-secularism. Neoracists denigrate European culture and elevate non-Europeanness. They thus consider Christianity to be the religion of the privileged and Islam the religion of the oppressed, leading to an absurdly complacent and positive attitude towards Islam, even though it is just as dangerous—arguably more so—than Christianity. Neoracists refuse to recognize the biological basis of race and racism, thus making the category error of conflating racial identity and religious affiliation and allowing them to make specious accusations of “racism” against those who criticize Islam. Finally, according to neoracist dogma, racism is always a one-way street, with whites being racist and non-whites targets of racism. Thus, neoracists refuse to recognize white-on-white racism such as anti-Québécois ethnic bigotry which is a major aspect of opposition to Quebec Bill 21.

When it comes to cowardice, it would be difficult to compete with ostensibly “secular” organizations in English Canada which oppose Bill 21…

When it comes to cowardice, it would be difficult to compete with ostensibly “secular” organizations in English Canada which oppose Bill 21 (and opposed the Charter of Secularism proposed by the PQ government in 2013-2014). Although they claim to support secularism, they hypocritically oppose it in the one place in North America—Québec—where secularism is making the most progress. By opposing Bill 21, such organizations are rejecting religion-State separation—the most important aspect of any secular program—and are thus antisecular. They are evidently incapable of freeing themselves from the assumption of religious privilege; that is, they cannot envisage treating religious ideologies fairly along with other ideologies by removing religion’s privileges.

Conclusion

If you support children’s rights, you will support restricting or banning unnecessary, irreversible medical interventions on underage persons, whether those practices are labelled female genital mutilation, male circumcision or the euphemistic “gender affirming care,” and regardless of the particular ideology used to rationalize such practices. You will also oppose the veiling of children.

If you support gay rights, you will oppose medically unnecessary procedures which attempt to change the sex of an underage individual, because studies have shown that a large proportion of young people suffering from gender dysphoria will, if allowed to mature without such procedures, grow up to be homosexual without gender dysphoria. In other words, applying such procedures prematurely often amounts to anti-gay conversion therapy. Furthermore, there is little evidence that medical transition decreases suicide rates.

If you support women’s rights, you will have no trouble defining the term “woman” objectively, as an adult female human.

If you oppose racism, you will oppose racist hiring practices and DIE programs in civil services, universities and all public institutions. You will support restoration of meritocracy.

If you support secularism, you will endorse religion-State separation and support legislation which bans civil servants, as well as public school and childcare centre personnel, from wearing religious and political symbols while on the job.

If you care about objective truth, you will speak up against the fanatical practices described in this article. To fear defamatory accusations is eminently reasonable, but you will not allow that fear to silence you. Remember the aphorism (attributed to Socrates, but I got it from Michael Sherlock): “When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser.”


Other Links


Next blog: Another Antisecular Screed Trashing Secularism in France…

Trudeau Appoints Anti-Québécois Racist to Combat so-called ‘Islamophobia’

Amira Elghawaby will stifle criticism of Islam & Islamism and fight against secularism.

2023-01-28

Canada’s irresponsible Prime Minister has appointed a notorious anti-Québécois racist to a well-funded office whose mandate is to combat so-called ‘Islamophobia,’ i.e. her job will be to censor blasphemy against Islam and Islamism.

Sommaire en français Le premier ministre irresponsable du Canada a nommé une raciste anti-québécoise mal famée à un poste bien financé dont le mandat est de lutter contre la soi-disant « islamophobie », c’est-à-dire que son travail consistera à censurer le blasphème contre l’islam et contre l’islamisme.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has appointed anti-Québécois bigot Amira Elghawaby as Canada’s first “Special representative on combating Islamophobia.” Elghawaby is well known for her opposition to secular legislation such as Quebec Bill 21. She worked for five years with the extremely dubious National Council of Canadian Muslims (NCCM). Recall that the NCCM promotes several retrograde policies, including weakening Canada’s national security agencies, which would make it easier for political Islam to infiltrate the country.

In 2021, University of Toronto philosophy professor Joseph Heath authored an article, published in the Globe & Mail, in which he observed that the American model of race relations does not at all apply to Canada and that, in particular, “the largest group of people in this country who were victimized by British colonialism, subjugated and incorporated into confederation by force, are French Canadians.” A cursory review of Canadian history is more than enough to confirm the validity of Heath’s statement: the hanging of Louis Riel, the deportation of Acadians, the activities of the Ku Klux Klan in Canada and in Maine, the closure of French-language schools in several provinces, the October Crisis of 1970, etc. And most recently, the fanatical opposition of English Canada to Quebec Bill 21.

Elghawaby was evidently outraged by professor Heath’s very reasonable declaration, because she tweeted that “I’m going to puke.” Such a statement reflects her hatred of the Québécois people. It also illustrates her desire to reserve the status of victim for herself and her Islamist colleagues who claim a monopoly on victimhood. The reality, of course, is that Islamists systematically weaponize anti-Québécois racism in order to demonize Quebec Bill 21 and the majority of Quebeckers who support it.

Ms. Elghawaby has slandered Quebec secularists by falsely alleging a link between Quebec Bill 21 and the Quebec City mosque massacre of 2017-01-29. Recall that the attack occurred years before Bill 21 was adopted and years after previous similar legislation—the Charter of Secularism proposed by the PQ government in 2013—was defeated. Similarly, she has also promoted the preposterous idea of a link between Quebec Bill 21 and the 2021-06-06 anti-Muslim attack in London, Ontario. Recall that Ontario is a different province.

Ms. Elghawaby’s incendiary pronouncements are irresponsible as they can only exacerbate social tensions which increase—not decrease—the risk of violent incidents. Secular legislation such as Quebec Bill 21 reduce social tensions by showing the population that their government is taking reasonable measures to reduce religious influence in civil institutions. Ms. Elghawaby, on the other hand, does everything she can to inflame such tensions.

Elghawaby’s office will have an initial budget of $5.6 million. As her mandate is to fight against so-called ‘Islamophobia,’ what this means in practice is that those funds will be used to censor criticism of Islam and Islamism and to propagate hatred of critics of those ideologies. Recall that the tendentious term ‘Islamophobia’ is basically a synonym for blasphemy against Islam. Recall as well that Islam specifies the death penalty for apostasy, i.e. leaving the faith, thus making it incompatible with fundamental freedoms. Furthermore, the Islamic religion, both in the quran and in various hadiths, propagates hatred of women, Jews, homosexuals, believers in other religions and non-believers. To fear Islam is certainly not a “phobia.” Rather, to fear Islam—especially its fundamentalist variant Islamism—is both prudent and necessary.

Furthermore, recall that Bill 21 puts no restriction whatsoever on freedom of belief. Rather, that law puts a restriction on freedom of religious expression (not belief) for civil servants in positions of authority and for public school teachers and principals, so as to provide civil service users and schoolchildren with an environment free from religious proselytism. Bill 21 applies only while on the job. There is no restriction whatsoever when the civil servant is not at work. Elghawaby’s refusal to accept this very reasonable restriction indicates that she is a religious fanatic—the worst sort of person whom the government could appoint to a position dealing with human rights.

Clearly, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is an incompetent fool to have made such an unwise appointment.

I happen to be familiar with Amira Elghawaby and her unctuous manners. I personally participated in two panel discussions recorded for the “Canadian Justice” television show in 2020 and 2021, panels in which I was the only person who supported Bill 21, outnumbered by the other panelists (including Ms. Elghawaby) and by the hosts of the show.


Sixth Anniversary of the Quebec City Mosque Attack

Recall that 29th January 2023 (tomorrow, relative to the date of this blog) is the sixth anniversary of that horrific attack on a mosque in Quebec City where six persons were killed and several other seriously wounded. We need to recall certain facts:

  • Islam and its fundamentalist variant Islamism are indeed dangerous ideologies as explained above.
  • Anti-Muslim violence, in addition to being utterly unconscionable and barbaric, is the worst possible response to that danger. Such violence only strengthens the hand of Islamists.
  • Incidents of anti-Muslim violence, such as the 2017 mosque attack, are unrelated to secular legislation, such as Quebec Bill 21, except to the extent that such legislation helps to reduce social tensions, thus reducing the risk of such violence.

Islamists and their dupes unscrupulously attempt to use such anti-Muslim violence as a propaganda tool against secular legislation. See, for example, my blog “No, We Are Not Guilty”, written at the time of the third anniversary of the attack.

See also:


Next blog: Burden of Proof

Bias in 2021 Election Leaders’ Debate

The Quebec Conseil de presse rules that moderator Shachi Kurl was biased.

2022-12-08

The Conseil de presse du Québec has ruled that moderator Shachi Kurl and CBC News lacked impartiality at the leaders’ debate, during the 2021 federal election campaign. Kurl asked a “question” which was in fact a specious and dishonest accusation of “racism” against Bill 21.

Sommaire en français La modératrice Shachi Kurl qui a posé une “question” qui était en réalité une spécieuse et malhonnête accusation de “racisme” contre la Loi 21 est l’objet d’une plainte retenue par le Conseil de presse du Québec.

During the 2021 Canadian federal election, a leaders’ debate in English was broadcast on several television networks on the evening of 9 septembre. The moderator of the debate was Shachi Kurl, president of the polling agency Angus Reid Institute.

In reponse to a complaint filed against CBC News and Ms. Kurl, the Quebec Conseil de presse ruled on 28 octobre 2022 that both had indeed lacked impartiality during the leaders’ debate. Kurl asked a “question” which was in fact an accusation of “racism” against Bill 21. Here is the transcript of the question/accusation for which CBC News and Ms. Kurl have been reprimanded:

“Mister Blanchet, to you. You deny that Québec has problems with racism, yet you defend legislations such as Bills 96 and 21 which marginalize religious minorities, anglophones and allophones. Québec is recognized as a distinct society, but for those outside the province, please help them understand why your party also supports these discriminatory laws.”

I wrote about this incident in a previous blog. This is how I summarized the situation:

“the association of Bill 21 with ‘racism’ which is part of Shachi Kurl’s ‘question’ is standard practice for the law’s opponents. Although the law obviously has nothing whatsoever to do with race or racism, opponents like Kurl irrationally and dishonestly conflate race with religion. This allows them to make specious accusations of racism, because defamation is their primary weapon in their war against secularism. Their constant use of such slander against secularists is proof of the vacuity of their arguments.”

This decision criticizing CBC News and Ms. Kurl, although little more than symbolic, is nevertheless very good news, because it shows recognition that slander and anti-Québécois bigotry are indeed tools used by opponents of secularism in order to vilify Quebec Bill 21.


Links


Next blog: Fourteen Observations about Post-Leftism

The CRTC, Pierre Vallières and Postmodernism

The recent CRTC decision, reprimanding Radio-Canada, is unjust and foolish.

2022-07-03 (Link added 2022-07-04)

Instead of puritanical censorship of mere words, we need to be able to discuss freely racism in general and, in particular, the issues raised by Pierre Vallières’ famous 1968 book, in which he drew parallels between anti-Black racism in the USA and anti-Francophone prejudice in Canada.

Sommaire en français Au lieu d’une censure puritaine des mots, nous devons pouvoir discuter librement du racisme en général et, en particulier, des questions soulevées par le livre célèbre de Pierre Vallières de 1968, dans lequel il établit un parallèle entre le racisme anti-Noirs aux États-Unis et le préjugé anti-francophones au Canada.

Recently (2022-06-29) the CRTC (Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission) reprimanded Radio-Canada for using the word « nègre » during a radio show without sufficient warning to listeners, calling on the broadcaster to make a formal apology. The word was used in the title of a book being discussed. Fortunately, two members of the Commission disagree with the majority decision and reject the complaint against R-C.

Unfortunately, the controversy over a mere word has obscured the real issue: the ideas in the book whose title contained the word. The Radio-Canada radio broadcast (2020-08-17) discussed those ideas, but the recent CRTC reprimand contains only condemnation of use of the word, without discussion of context. So we need to recall that context.

In 1966, Pierre Vallières, writer, journalist and FLQ activist (Front de Libération du Québec), took refuge in the USA with the help of the Black Panthers. He was arrested for participating in a demonstration before UN headquarters in New York City and was imprisoned for several months. During that period in prison, he wrote the now famous book Nègres blancs d’Amérique, published in 1968, in which he drew certain parallels between the situation of French-speaking Québécois in Canada and Blacks in the USA and expressed solidarity between the two liberation movements.

The word « nègre » in French is roughly equivalent to the English word “negro” which was considered correct at the time. If you put « sale » (dirty) in front of it, then the French word becomes racist, but of course you could put « sale » in front of « blanc » or any other colour and the result could be a racist insult. But taken alone, « nègre » does not have the extreme racist connotations and enormous emotional charge of that other English word, six letters beginning with “n” and ending with “r” and which I cannot even mention here without risking serious repercussions. However, when Vallières’ book was published in English translation, it was precisely that very strong n-word which the publisher chose to use in the title. I assume they did so because they wanted the title to be hard-hitting and highly charged. I think they succeeded.

Francophone men in Quebec were in a slightly worse position (compared to Anglophones) than Afro-American men in the USA (relative to whites).

Vallières’ parallel between the Québécois and Afro-Americans was not spurious. It is important to recall the economic situation of Francophones in Quebec at the time. In the 1960s, the Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism, known also as the Laurendeau-Dunton Commission, was set up by the federal government to study the relative situations of the English and French languages and cultures in Canada. Among its findings were that, in 1960, in Quebec, the average employment income of unilingual French-speaking men was 51% of that of unilingual men of British descent. At the same time, in the United States, the average employment income of black men was 56% of that of white men. In other words, Francophone men in Quebec were in a slightly worse position (compared to Anglophones) than Afro-American men in the USA (relative to whites).

This was not to suggest that the two situations were identical. The history of slavery in the USA and the racist propaganda which was used to legitimize the enslavement of Blacks are specific to that country. Vallières’ intent was to express solidarity among oppressed peoples, not to ignore the variety of different forms of oppression.

The CRTC’s dreadful decision to censure Radio-Canada for merely quoting a book title is not the first time that antiracist intentions have degenerated into puritanical censorship. Remember the dismissal of Wendy Mesley in 2020 for quoting Vallières’ title. (And I understand this occurred during a preparatory meeting, not even on the air!) Let us hope that Radio-Canada management does not capitulate and respond with the same abject cowardice which the CBC displayed in the Mesley case.

We should also not forget that this Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism was the seed from which the Canadian Multiculturalism Act eventually developed. But that development was a corruption of the original intent. Biculturalism began as a consideration of Canada’s two founding European peoples, the British and French. But over time, that concept faded, to be replaced by multiculturalism which reduced the French to just one minority culture among many, thus assuring the dominance of English language and culture in Canada.

Antisecularism and Postmodernism

Although the situation has evolved considerably since Vallières’ time, anti-Québécois prejudice is nevertheless still present today. It has been recycled and weaponized by antisecularists in order to denigrate Quebec’s secular legislation, Bill 21. In fact, obscuring the content of Vallières’ analysis by censoring its title, as the CRTC is attempting to do, plays right into the hands of those antisecularists. Some particularly dishonest opponents of Bill 21 even accuse that law (and by implication, Quebecers who strongly support it) of “racism.” Their hypocrisy is blatant, for it is they who are using a racist prejudice to oppose the law.

…the obsession with “offensive” words is a particular preoccupation of the anti-Enlightenment pseudo-left…

In general, the obsession with “offensive” words is a particular preoccupation of the anti-Enlightenment pseudo-left (a.k.a. the “woke”). It is based on the postmodernist idea of the power of language. As Pluckrose and Lindsay explain in Cynical Theories (page 60),

“The power and danger of language are foregrounded in all the new applied postmodern Theories. […] the idea that words are powerful and dangerous has now become widespread and underlies much scholarship and activism around discursive (or verbal) violence, safe spaces, microaggressions, and trigger warnings.”

Put succinctly, the “woke” choose to conflate words with physical violence.

In this particular case, pseudo-leftists refuse to recognize the existence of the anti-Québécois prejudice which Vallières denounced in his title because most Québécois have the wrong skin colour. Furthermore, pseudo-leftists tend to be resolutely antisecular by virtue of their racialization of religious affiliation. Objecting to an “offensive” word in the title is a convenient distraction from the issues which Vallières raised.


Relevant Links


Next blog: Stillbirth, The Failure of Secularism in the English-Speaking World

The Great Canadian Euphemism

Bonne Fête nationale québécoise !

2022-06-24, Addendum 2022-06-26

In his speech before the Académie française, Quebec Minister of the French Language Simon Jolin-Barrette was totally correct in denouncing Canadian multiculturalism, as well as defamatory reactions against Bills 21 and 96 by English-language media.

Sommaire en français Dans son discours devant l’Académie française, le ministre québécois de la Langue française, Simon Jolin-Barrette, a eu tout à fait raison de dénoncer le multiculturalisme canadien, ainsi que les propos diffamatoires des médias anglophones contre les Lois 21 et 96.

Yesterday, 23rd June 2022, Simon Jolin-Barrette, Quebec Minister of the French Language, gave a formal speech before the Académie française in Paris. It was an exceptional moment, for rarely does the Académie invite foreigners to make such an address. Moreover, this is the first time in its nearly 400 year history that an elected representative who is neither head of State nor head of a government has been so invited.

As Quebec recently adopted legislation, Bill 96, which updates and reforms its Charte de la langue française, adopted in 1977 and known colloquially as Bill 101, Jolin-Barrette’s theme was, not surprisingly, the protection and reinforcement of the French language. He invited France to partner with Quebec with that goal in mind.

Jolin-Barrette referred to the increasing predominance of the English language and technology giants known as GAFAM as the “Anglo-American steamroller.” But it was perhaps his comments critical of multiculturalism—hardly controversial for the French—which ruffled the most feathers back home in this country, especially among Anglo-Canadians:

Although our project is thwarted by Canadian multiculturalism, which finds an equivalent in what you call communitarianism and which fights Quebec’s claims to be a distinct nation, the French language must truly become the language of use for all Quebecers…

He also denounced how many English-language media, both Canadian and American, have defamed Quebec and denigrated the actions of his government, particularly with regard to the secularism law (Bill 21) as well as Bill 96. Such media have endeavoured to paint those laws as regressive and authoritarian. But in his opinion, “Our fight for the French language is just, it is a universal fight, that of a nation that has peacefully resisted the will to power of the strongest.”

Simon Jolin-Barrette is absolutely right on both counts: (1) the perniciousness of the Canadian ideology of multiculturalism and (2) the defamatory reaction against Bills 21 and 96.

Canadian multiculturalism is a dishonest euphemism whose true meaning is cultural relativism, clientelism and a bigotry of low expectations, treating minorities as static, well circumscribed and distinct from the majority. It represents the death of universalism and a return to tribalism. A prime example of the consequences of multiculturalism is the experience of Yasmine Mohammed who, after suffering much abuse as a teenager at the hands of her pious Muslim step-father, was abandoned by Canadian authorities, both police and judge, who refused to take action because “different cultures are free to discipline their children in different ways.” Other consequences include all sorts of so-called “reasonable accommodations” (which should instead be called “unreasonable religious accommodations”) such as depriving children of music because of their parents’ religion, allowing—even celebrating—the veiling of young girls, thus endorsing a form of child abuse, allowing civil servants to wear religious symbols while on duty (which Bill 21 bans in Quebec) and so on.

The Québécois oppose Canadian multiculturalism because it reduces them to just another minority, which leads inexorably to Anglo-supremacy. Under Canadian multiculturalism, every language is reduced to folklore status, except English of course. Bravo Quebec for standing up for cultural and linguistic diversity!

Canadian multiculturalism is incompatible with secularism, because secularism requires that all citizens be treated equally, regardless of their religious affiliation or lack thereof. Neither Christians, nor atheists, nor Muslims, nor any other specific group should be allowed to display their personal religious opinions or identity while working in the civil service. This is called universalism and it is a core value of secularism. Those Anglo-Canadians who claim to be secularists need to face that reality.

Multiculturalism is the Great Canadian Euphemism. Proponents of this retrograde ideology arrogate to themselves the moral high ground, as if anyone who criticizes it were morally stunted or even “racist.” Their hypocrisy is obvious. Not only is multiculturalism a throwback to tribal days before the advent of universal human rights, it is also a tool used by anti-secularists to rationalize their anti-Québécois ethnic bigotry.

On this 24th of June 2022, a holiday here in Quebec, the Fête nationale, we celebrate Québécois language and culture. (This blog is in English because Anglo-Canadians are the ones who most need to read it.) Taking steps to protect the French language in Quebec is in everyone’s interest, including English-speakers, because without it, Canada and North America would be culturally much poorer. Without French language and culture, without Quebec, would Canada be anything more than a pale replica of the USA?

Addendum

Here is another example of Canadian multiculturalism in action: No child protection for Syrian refugee punched and lashed in N.S. for texting with a boy

Authorities used confusion about the victim’s age as an excuse to do nothing. The teenage girl was the target of a severe beating, enough to break her nose apparently. Whether she was 15 or 16 at the time, her father must be held accountable. But this is Canada. Would this have been allowed if the family were not immigrants from a Muslim country?


Next blog: Flawed Constitutions