The Question is Not IF but Rather WHERE
2025-12-28
Separation between religions and State requires banning religious symbols worn on the job by at least some civil servants and school personnel. Thus, the question for secularists is not whether to ban, but rather where, in what contexts, bans are necessary to protect freedom of conscience.
Sommaire en français
La séparation des religions et de l’État nécessite l’interdiction du port de signes religieux au travail par au moins certains fonctionnaires et membres du personnel scolaire. Ainsi, pour les laïques, la question n’est pas de savoir si, oui ou non, il faut interdire, mais plutôt où et dans quels contextes une telle interdiction est nécessaire pour protéger la liberté de conscience.
This article sets forth how the debate about secularism should, in my opinion, be framed, i.e. the context in which the debate should occur. I am thinking in particular of the ban on religious symbols worn by civil servants and teachers while on duty. By “the debate” I do not mean the disagreement between those who support such bans and those who oppose them. No, I mean the disagreement between (1) those who are of the opinion that secularists may agree or disagree with such bans, and (2) those who affirm that secularists must necessarily support such bans, at least in some circumstances, but may differ in the details. It is this latter disagreement which must be addressed by the debate.
If you are familiar with my previous writing about these issues, then you already know that I favour the approach (2) and reject (1). Here, I will explain why it is important to frame the debate in this way.
One of the core principles of secularism is the separation between religions and State, i.e. taking whatever measures are reasonably necessary to prevent religious interference with the affairs of the State, such as legislation, civil services and public education. In order to prevent State employees from engaging in proselytism, whether active or passive, it is necessary (but not sufficient) to ban such employees from wearing political, religious or commercial symbols while on duty. Just as we would not want a judge or schoolteacher to wear a partisan political symbol while on duty, we must have similar objections to conspicuous crucifixes, hijabs or other religious emblems worn on the employee’s person.
Varieties of Proselytism
Proselytism includes a variety of behaviours ranging from directly trying to recruit others to join one’s religion, to imposing one’s religion on others, to simply advertising it. It may occur within a single religion, i.e. the target may be of the same religion as the proselytizer. One obvious example is a pious Muslim trying to convince a less devout Muslim woman that she should wear the veil in order to be a “good” Muslim.
Proselytism…may occur within a single religion, i.e. the target may be of the same religion as the proselytizer.
When the person doing the advertising (or imposing or attempting to convert) is an agent of the State, especially if they are in a position of authority, then that person is using their status and authority to influence others. It is a form of religious interference in State affairs. This is especially serious if the person deals with children who are particularly vulnerable to indoctrination. This is not difficult to understand. It is obvious to anyone who supports the principle of separation between religion and State.
To remove religious symbols while working for the State is a small and reasonable restriction on religious practice—but which has no effect on religious belief. It is a mere inconvenience for the person involved (no matter how loudly they may whine), but has a major benefit for everyone: the absence of religious partisanship and of proselytizing in civil services.
No, We Cannot Agree to Disagree
Thus, if one espouses secularism, one must necessarily accept the notion that banning religious symbols for at least some State employees is the appropriate thing to do. Secularists may disagree on secondary questions. For example, should such bans apply to all civil servants, or only to those who are in regular contact with the public, or only to those in positions of authority? Should sitting members of a legislative assembly be exempted from such bans because they are primarily elected representatives and not considered to be agents of the State?
[…] to oppose all bans on religious symbols in all situations is an extremist, anti-secular position, leaving the door wide open to abuse.
However, to oppose all bans on religious symbols in all situations is an extremist, anti-secular position, leaving the door wide open to abuse. Not only is the principle of separation thus violated, but the freedom of conscience of schoolchildren and civil service users is undermined by allowing school personnel and State employees to advertise their religion (or their political convictions) on the job.
Thus, any person or organization claiming to support secularism but opposing all religious symbol bans is not only anti-secular, but also hypocritical, flagrantly betraying the very secularism they purport to uphold. Neutrality regarding such bans is not a valid option either, because it constitutes a cowardly failure to do the right thing, a failure to protect the freedom of conscience of the citizenry from religious proselytism.
The Urgent Situation in Quebec and Canada
Currently, a legal challenge to Quebec’s Bill 21, which bans religious symbols for some State employees and declares that all persons have a right to secular institutions and public services, is upcoming in the Supreme Court of Canada. The list of organizations and individuals attacking the Bill, some religious but certainly not all, is long and disturbing, indicating just how deep and widespread is the ideological capture of various institutions in our society. Particularly disturbing is the influence which political Islam has already achieved.
If political Islam were not an issue, legislation such as Bill 21 would still be necessary, although less urgent. However, the situation is indeed urgent. All religions are potentially dangerous, while the three Abrahamic religions—Judaism, Christianity and Islam—are particularly toxic. Islam in particular, if applied fully, promotes several brutal practices such as criminalization of apostasy and homosexuality, with severe penalties, as well as the denigration of women. In North America, Muslims represent a small minority while Islamists represent a minority among Muslims, Nevertheless, Islamists have enormous influence in Canada, far beyond what one would expect given their small numbers. The reason for this is obvious: they have many allies among non-Muslims, even among atheists, many of whom have become enthralled by various identitarian ideologies which promote cultural relativism and strongly emphasize personal identities to the detriment of universal human rights.
Accusations of “Islamophobia” function as a de facto prohibition on blasphemy against one particular religion.
A particularly egregious example of this alliance is the Canadian government’s appointment of a “special representative on combatting Islamophobia” whose evident task is to promote religious privileges for Islam. Accusations of “Islamophobia” function as a de facto prohibition on blasphemy against one particular religion. The situation in Europe is worse than in North America, but it is only a matter of time before the influence of political Islam becomes a serious threat to our quality of life.
The non-Muslim allies and facilitators of Islamism remain complacent, wilfully blind to the various strategies of political Islam. The game plan includes promotion of the veil, specious accusations of “Islamophobia” in order to silence critics, proliferation of halal products, playing the victim and the use of the concept of human rights as a weapon against human rights. One example of this last strategy is the use of false accusations of “discrimination” thrown against secular legislation such as Bill 21. Another is the racialization and essentialization of religious affiliation (a process which negates freedom of conscience) in order to denigrate secular legislation with bizarre accusations of “racism.”
Who is Doing the Discrimination?
The accusation that Bill 21 “discriminates” against anyone is patently false. The legislation applies to all persons, regardless of sex, regardless of religious affiliation or lack thereof. To accuse Bill 21 of discrimination (whether against women, or against Muslims or against any other group) is like accusing anti-theft laws of discrimination against thieves, or accusing speed limits of discrimination against owners of fast cars. A person who wears a religious symbol and who refuses to remove it, even at work, even in the civil service or a public school, is either a fanatic or an unwitting agent of fanatics who are using that person to advance their politico-religious agenda. It is misogynistic religions which discriminate against women, while secular legislation does precisely the opposite, discouraging displays of the symbols of such misogyny.
Secularism…must also protect the religious believer from their own community, allowing the individual to set their own course in life […]
I have insisted on religion-State separation as an essential principle of secularism. Another major principle is freedom of conscience. The purpose of the former is to protect the latter. Secularism must of course protect the individual from the undue imposition of other religions or convictions. But it must also protect the religious believer from their own community, allowing the individual to set their own course in life, either as a member of that group, or not, as they choose. Similarly, secularism must protect children from the religion of their family, offering a universalist education and vision of the world, so that each child may chart their own path as they mature into adulthood.
Religious & Political
Allowing teachers or civil servants to advertise their religious affiliation on the job prejudices the teaching and civil service environments, so as to maintain pre-existing communities, pre-existing boundaries, isolating groups from each other in an unhealthy manner. There is no reason to elevate some convictions—the religious—as more important, more essential, more “sacred” than others—such as political ones. Indeed, a religious symbol worn by a civil servant on the job becomes a political symbol in that context.
What we are witnessing here is a vestige of British colonialism […]
Finally, many of the opponents challenging Quebec Bill 21 before the Supreme Court of Canada are from outside Quebec. What we are witnessing here is a vestige of British colonialism, where non-Quebeckers are attempting to interfere in the affairs of a province, indeed a nation, thus flouting Quebec’s autonomy within the Canadian federation. English Canadians who claim to be secularists have a duty to support secular legislation in Quebec, or at the very least refrain from impeding it. Instead, many have thrown Quebec secularists under the bus, by allying themselves with obscurantist religious movements. I will not “agree to disagree” with such duplicity. I condemn it.
Next blog: Quebec: Vanguard of Secularism in North America