L’exemption religieuse doit disparaütre

David Rand,
Président de Libres penseurs athées et porte-parole du Rassemblement pour la laïcité

Date de publication : 2026-05-12

Ce texte est une rĂ©ponse, refusĂ©e par le journal, Ă  un article de La Presse, paru en mars. Vu que le projet de loi C-9 n’est toujours pas adoptĂ© (il est en comitĂ© sĂ©natorial), j’ai dĂ©cidĂ© de publier cette rĂ©ponse ici. L’exemption religieuse constitue un privilĂšge accordĂ© aux textes religieux et aux croyants, au dĂ©triment des incroyants.

Summary in English Bill C-9 has still not been adopted by the federal government. It is before a Senate committee. The religious exemption in Canada’s hate propaganda legislation constitutes a privilege granted to religious texts and believers, to the detriment of non-believers.

Dans un texte paru dans La Presse du 19 mars 2026, Jean-Christophe Jasmin de l’Institut Cardus dĂ©clare que l’exemption religieuse dans la loi canadienne sur la propagande haineuse doit rester. Il s’agit, selon lui, de protĂ©ger la libertĂ© d’expression en matiĂšre de religion. Il en vient Ă  souhaiter le rejet du projet de loi fĂ©dĂ©ral C-9.

Je suis d’accord avec M. Jasmin sur un point : le PL-C-9 pose certains problĂšmes. La caractĂ©risation de la haine dans ce projet de loi est dangereusement imprĂ©cise, ouvrant la porte aux abus. De plus, comme le souligne M. Jasmin, le PL-C-9 retire la condition que « toute poursuite exige l’accord formel du procureur gĂ©nĂ©ral Â».

Mais depuis la premiĂšre version du projet de loi, l’abrogation de l’exception religieuse (alinĂ©as 319(3)b et 319(3.1)b) y a Ă©tĂ© ajoutĂ©e. La disparition de cette aberrante exception serait une excellente nouvelle, en fait le seul aspect positif du PL-C-9. Mais c’est prĂ©cisĂ©ment cette exception que M. Jasmin veut prĂ©server !

Rappelons que le texte de cette exception accorde l’impunitĂ© Ă  l’individu qui exprime « une opinion sur un sujet religieux ou une opinion fondĂ©e sur un texte religieux auquel il croit Â». Selon M. Jasmin, la crainte que cette disposition confĂšre une immunitĂ© aux discours religieux est infondĂ©e car ce texte protĂšge non seulement l’expression de la croyance religieuse mais aussi, selon lui, la critique des religions. Mais a-t-il bien lu ?

La deuxiĂšme moitiĂ© du passage citĂ©, « une opinion fondĂ©e sur un texte religieux auquel il croit Â», accorde Ă©videmment un avantage aux croyants : le texte dit clairement que si on croit Ă  un certain texte religieux dont l’expression peut ĂȘtre considĂ©rĂ©e haineuse, alors le croyant est innocentĂ©.

[…] pourquoi accorder un tel statut privilĂ©giĂ© aux textes religieux, les rendant susceptibles d’innocenter une personne qui y croit mais qui serait coupable de propagande haineuse si elle n’y croyait pas ? Pourquoi un texte religieux aurait-il un tel pouvoir magique,[…]

Dans les paragraphes 319(3) et 319(3.1), il y a quatre exceptions qui accordent l’impunitĂ©. La premiĂšre, par exemple, stipule que l’individu ne peut ĂȘtre condamnĂ© si ses dĂ©clarations sont vraies. Donc, la vĂ©ritĂ© ne peut ĂȘtre interprĂ©tĂ©e comme de la propagande haineuse. Excellent. Selon M. Jasmin, toutes les quatre exemptions servent « Ă€ protĂ©ger la libertĂ© d’expression, en fait. Â» Bien que cela soit vrai pour trois exemptions parmi les quatre, l’exemption religieuse, elle, va bien plus loin car elle constitue un privilĂšge religieux. En effet, pourquoi accorder un tel statut privilĂ©giĂ© aux textes religieux, les rendant susceptibles d’innocenter une personne qui y croit mais qui serait coupable de propagande haineuse si elle n’y croyait pas ? Pourquoi un texte religieux aurait-il un tel pouvoir magique, non accordĂ© aux textes philosophiques, scientifiques, littĂ©raires ou autres ?

Ce privilĂšge devient encore plus Ă©vident quand on regarde l’histoire de cette exception religieuse dans la lĂ©gislation. Avant le projet de loi C-250 en 2003, l’exception religieuse ne faisait pas rĂ©fĂ©rence Ă  un texte religieux. Le trĂšs simple PL-C-250 a fait deux choses : (1) ajouter l’orientation sexuelle dans la dĂ©finition de « groupe identifiable Â», et (2) renforcer l’exception religieuse en y ajoutant cette rĂ©fĂ©rence Ă  un texte religieux. Il suffit de lire le Hansard des dĂ©bats au sujet du PL-C-250 pour constater le lien avec l’homophobie chrĂ©tienne de certains dĂ©putĂ©s Ă  l’époque.

En gardant ce privilĂšge religieux dans la loi sur la propagande haineuse, comme le propose Jean-Christophe Jasmin, l’État canadien continuerait Ă  entĂ©riner, dans son Code criminel, la nature soi-disant « sacrĂ©e Â» des textes religieux et il continuerait Ă  discriminer les incroyants. Il s’agit d’une atteinte Ă  la neutralitĂ© religieuse de l’État et ainsi une atteinte Ă  la laĂŻcitĂ©.


Voir aussi : L’exemption religieuse crĂ©e une asymĂ©trie difficilement justifiable, Me Éric Ouellet, La Presse, 2026-03-21.


Prochain blogue : Two Distinct Types of Conversion Therapy

Quebec: Vanguard of Secularism in North America

Free Inquiry

2026-02-13

The article Quebec: Vanguard of Secularism in North America is published on the website of the American freethought magazine Free Inquiry, published by the Center for Inquiry (CFI) in the USA. A few excerpts from the article are shown below.

Sommaire en français Ce texte, « Le QuĂ©bec, Ă  l’avant-garde en matiĂšre de laĂŻcitĂ© en AmĂ©rique du Nord Â» est paru sur le site web de la revue amĂ©ricaine Free Inquiry, une publication du Center for Inquiry (CFI) aux États-Unis. En voici quelques extraits.

[…]

On June 16, 2019, Quebec adopted Bill 21, Loi sur la laĂŻcitĂ© de l’État or An Act respecting the laicity of the State. The word “laicity” is a dubious translation from the French “laĂŻcitĂ©â€ and should arguably be replaced by the more familiar English term secularism. Nevertheless, the use of that term in this legislation is a reminder that Quebec takes its cue from France, where secularism necessarily includes the principle of separation between religion and state, not merely religious neutrality. Whereas in the English-speaking world, the separation principle tends to be given only lip service.

[…]

Another law, Bill 9 or An Act respecting the reinforcement of laicity in QuĂ©bec, was proposed by the Quebec government on November 27. This bill would implement several of the Pelchat-Rousseau Committee’s recommendations. […] Unfortunately, Bill 9 as proposed, Bill 94 as adopted, and Bill 21 as adopted some six years previously, contain no provision to curtail the fiscal privileges currently granted to religious institutions. Furthermore, all three contain a so-called “grandfather” clause that allows an exemption from the religious symbol ban for employees on staff when the law was first proposed. Thus, much remains to be done. Nevertheless, each of these bills constitutes a major step forward.

While Quebec makes steady progress toward secularism, Canada at the federal level stagnates as a soft theocracy (to borrow an expression from Australian secularist Max Wallace). Canada’s head of state is King Charles III, also titular head of the Church of England. The very first line of the Constitution Act of 1982 (which is also the first line of the much-overrated Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms) declares that “Canada is founded upon principles that recognize the supremacy of God and the rule of law.” (Note also the oxymoronic nature of that declaration.)

[…]

Federal Canadian legislation is riddled with religious privileges, probably the most egregious being the religious exception (paragraphs 319(3)b and 319(3.1)), in the Hate Propaganda section of the Criminal Code, which grants immunity to religious speech.

[…]

Support for and opposition to Bill 21 are almost perfectly aligned with linguistic differences. Secularism enjoys overwhelming support from the Quebec population. Secular organizations in Quebec are unanimous in their support. But in Canada outside Quebec, the opposition from politicians and media is ferocious, often expressed in extreme language containing elements of anti-Québécois ethnic bigotry. Nevertheless, even in English Canada, popular opinion does not necessarily agree with the knee-jerk opposition so obvious among political and media elites.

[…]

See also:


Next blog: Supreme Court Must Respect Quebec’s Democratic Choice of Bill 21

Framing the Religious Symbol Debate

The Question is Not IF but Rather WHERE

2025-12-28

Separation between religions and State requires banning religious symbols worn on the job by at least some civil servants and school personnel. Thus, the question for secularists is not whether to ban, but rather where, in what contexts, bans are necessary to protect freedom of conscience.

Sommaire en français La sĂ©paration des religions et de l’État nĂ©cessite l’interdiction du port de signes religieux au travail par au moins certains fonctionnaires et membres du personnel scolaire. Ainsi, pour les laĂŻques, la question n’est pas de savoir si, oui ou non, il faut interdire, mais plutĂŽt oĂč et dans quels contextes une telle interdiction est nĂ©cessaire pour protĂ©ger la libertĂ© de conscience.

This article sets forth how the debate about secularism should, in my opinion, be framed, i.e. the context in which the debate should occur. I am thinking in particular of the ban on religious symbols worn by civil servants and teachers while on duty. By “the debate” I do not mean the disagreement between those who support such bans and those who oppose them. No, I mean the disagreement between (1) those who are of the opinion that secularists may agree or disagree with such bans, and (2) those who affirm that secularists must necessarily support such bans, at least in some circumstances, but may differ in the details. It is this latter disagreement which must be addressed by the debate.

If you are familiar with my previous writing about these issues, then you already know that I favour the approach (2) and reject (1). Here, I will explain why it is important to frame the debate in this way.

One of the core principles of secularism is the separation between religions and State, i.e. taking whatever measures are reasonably necessary to prevent religious interference with the affairs of the State, such as legislation, civil services and public education. In order to prevent State employees from engaging in proselytism, whether active or passive, it is necessary (but not sufficient) to ban such employees from wearing political, religious or commercial symbols while on duty. Just as we would not want a judge or schoolteacher to wear a partisan political symbol while on duty, we must have similar objections to conspicuous crucifixes, hijabs or other religious emblems worn on the employee’s person.

Varieties of Proselytism

Proselytism includes a variety of behaviours ranging from directly trying to recruit others to join one’s religion, to imposing one’s religion on others, to simply advertising it. It may occur within a single religion, i.e. the target may be of the same religion as the proselytizer. One obvious example is a pious Muslim trying to convince a less devout Muslim woman that she should wear the veil in order to be a “good” Muslim.

Proselytism…may occur within a single religion, i.e. the target may be of the same religion as the proselytizer.

When the person doing the advertising (or imposing or attempting to convert) is an agent of the State, especially if they are in a position of authority, then that person is using their status and authority to influence others. It is a form of religious interference in State affairs. This is especially serious if the person deals with children who are particularly vulnerable to indoctrination. This is not difficult to understand. It is obvious to anyone who supports the principle of separation between religion and State.

To remove religious symbols while working for the State is a small and reasonable restriction on religious practice—but which has no effect on religious belief. It is a mere inconvenience for the person involved (no matter how loudly they may whine), but has a major benefit for everyone: the absence of religious partisanship and of proselytizing in civil services.

No, We Cannot Agree to Disagree

Thus, if one espouses secularism, one must necessarily accept the notion that banning religious symbols for at least some State employees is the appropriate thing to do. Secularists may disagree on secondary questions. For example, should such bans apply to all civil servants, or only to those who are in regular contact with the public, or only to those in positions of authority? Should sitting members of a legislative assembly be exempted from such bans because they are primarily elected representatives and not considered to be agents of the State?

[…] to oppose all bans on religious symbols in all situations is an extremist, anti-secular position, leaving the door wide open to abuse.

However, to oppose all bans on religious symbols in all situations is an extremist, anti-secular position, leaving the door wide open to abuse. Not only is the principle of separation thus violated, but the freedom of conscience of schoolchildren and civil service users is undermined by allowing school personnel and State employees to advertise their religion (or their political convictions) on the job.

Thus, any person or organization claiming to support secularism but opposing all religious symbol bans is not only anti-secular, but also hypocritical, flagrantly betraying the very secularism they purport to uphold. Neutrality regarding such bans is not a valid option either, because it constitutes a cowardly failure to do the right thing, a failure to protect the freedom of conscience of the citizenry from religious proselytism.

The Urgent Situation in Quebec and Canada

Currently, a legal challenge to Quebec’s Bill 21, which bans religious symbols for some State employees and declares that all persons have a right to secular institutions and public services, is upcoming in the Supreme Court of Canada. The list of organizations and individuals attacking the Bill, some religious but certainly not all, is long and disturbing, indicating just how deep and widespread is the ideological capture of various institutions in our society. Particularly disturbing is the influence which political Islam has already achieved.

If political Islam were not an issue, legislation such as Bill 21 would still be necessary, although less urgent. However, the situation is indeed urgent. All religions are potentially dangerous, while the three Abrahamic religions—Judaism, Christianity and Islam—are particularly toxic. Islam in particular, if applied fully, promotes several brutal practices such as criminalization of apostasy and homosexuality, with severe penalties, as well as the denigration of women. In North America, Muslims represent a small minority while Islamists represent a minority among Muslims, Nevertheless, Islamists have enormous influence in Canada, far beyond what one would expect given their small numbers. The reason for this is obvious: they have many allies among non-Muslims, even among atheists, many of whom have become enthralled by various identitarian ideologies which promote cultural relativism and strongly emphasize personal identities to the detriment of universal human rights.

Accusations of “Islamophobia” function as a de facto prohibition on blasphemy against one particular religion.

A particularly egregious example of this alliance is the Canadian government’s appointment of a “special representative on combatting Islamophobia” whose evident task is to promote religious privileges for Islam. Accusations of “Islamophobia” function as a de facto prohibition on blasphemy against one particular religion. The situation in Europe is worse than in North America, but it is only a matter of time before the influence of political Islam becomes a serious threat to our quality of life.

The non-Muslim allies and facilitators of Islamism remain complacent, wilfully blind to the various strategies of political Islam. The game plan includes promotion of the veil, specious accusations of “Islamophobia” in order to silence critics, proliferation of halal products, playing the victim and the use of the concept of human rights as a weapon against human rights. One example of this last strategy is the use of false accusations of “discrimination” thrown against secular legislation such as Bill 21. Another is the racialization and essentialization of religious affiliation (a process which negates freedom of conscience) in order to denigrate secular legislation with bizarre accusations of “racism.”

Who is Doing the Discrimination?

The accusation that Bill 21 “discriminates” against anyone is patently false. The legislation applies to all persons, regardless of sex, regardless of religious affiliation or lack thereof. To accuse Bill 21 of discrimination (whether against women, or against Muslims or against any other group) is like accusing anti-theft laws of discrimination against thieves, or accusing speed limits of discrimination against owners of fast cars. A person who wears a religious symbol and who refuses to remove it, even at work, even in the civil service or a public school, is either a fanatic or an unwitting agent of fanatics who are using that person to advance their politico-religious agenda. It is misogynistic religions which discriminate against women, while secular legislation does precisely the opposite, discouraging displays of the symbols of such misogyny.

Secularism…must also protect the religious believer from their own community, allowing the individual to set their own course in life […]

I have insisted on religion-State separation as an essential principle of secularism. Another major principle is freedom of conscience. The purpose of the former is to protect the latter. Secularism must of course protect the individual from the undue imposition of other religions or convictions. But it must also protect the religious believer from their own community, allowing the individual to set their own course in life, either as a member of that group, or not, as they choose. Similarly, secularism must protect children from the religion of their family, offering a universalist education and vision of the world, so that each child may chart their own path as they mature into adulthood.

Religious & Political

Allowing teachers or civil servants to advertise their religious affiliation on the job prejudices the teaching and civil service environments, so as to maintain pre-existing communities, pre-existing boundaries, isolating groups from each other in an unhealthy manner. There is no reason to elevate some convictions—the religious—as more important, more essential, more “sacred” than others—such as political ones. Indeed, a religious symbol worn by a civil servant on the job becomes a political symbol in that context.

What we are witnessing here is a vestige of British colonialism […]

Finally, many of the opponents challenging Quebec Bill 21 before the Supreme Court of Canada are from outside Quebec. What we are witnessing here is a vestige of British colonialism, where non-Quebeckers are attempting to interfere in the affairs of a province, indeed a nation, thus flouting Quebec’s autonomy within the Canadian federation. English Canadians who claim to be secularists have a duty to support secular legislation in Quebec, or at the very least refrain from impeding it. Instead, many have thrown Quebec secularists under the bus, by allying themselves with obscurantist religious movements. I will not “agree to disagree” with such duplicity. I condemn it.


Next blog: Quebec: Vanguard of Secularism in North America

The Great Canadian Euphemism

Bonne FĂȘte nationale quĂ©bĂ©coise !

2022-06-24, Addendum 2022-06-26

In his speech before the Académie française, Quebec Minister of the French Language Simon Jolin-Barrette was totally correct in denouncing Canadian multiculturalism, as well as defamatory reactions against Bills 21 and 96 by English-language media.

Sommaire en français Dans son discours devant l’AcadĂ©mie française, le ministre quĂ©bĂ©cois de la Langue française, Simon Jolin-Barrette, a eu tout Ă  fait raison de dĂ©noncer le multiculturalisme canadien, ainsi que les propos diffamatoires des mĂ©dias anglophones contre les Lois 21 et 96.

Yesterday, 23rd June 2022, Simon Jolin-Barrette, Quebec Minister of the French Language, gave a formal speech before the Académie française in Paris. It was an exceptional moment, for rarely does the Académie invite foreigners to make such an address. Moreover, this is the first time in its nearly 400 year history that an elected representative who is neither head of State nor head of a government has been so invited.

As Quebec recently adopted legislation, Bill 96, which updates and reforms its Charte de la langue française, adopted in 1977 and known colloquially as Bill 101, Jolin-Barrette’s theme was, not surprisingly, the protection and reinforcement of the French language. He invited France to partner with Quebec with that goal in mind.

Jolin-Barrette referred to the increasing predominance of the English language and technology giants known as GAFAM as the “Anglo-American steamroller.” But it was perhaps his comments critical of multiculturalism—hardly controversial for the French—which ruffled the most feathers back home in this country, especially among Anglo-Canadians:

Although our project is thwarted by Canadian multiculturalism, which finds an equivalent in what you call communitarianism and which fights Quebec’s claims to be a distinct nation, the French language must truly become the language of use for all Quebecers…

He also denounced how many English-language media, both Canadian and American, have defamed Quebec and denigrated the actions of his government, particularly with regard to the secularism law (Bill 21) as well as Bill 96. Such media have endeavoured to paint those laws as regressive and authoritarian. But in his opinion, “Our fight for the French language is just, it is a universal fight, that of a nation that has peacefully resisted the will to power of the strongest.”

Simon Jolin-Barrette is absolutely right on both counts: (1) the perniciousness of the Canadian ideology of multiculturalism and (2) the defamatory reaction against Bills 21 and 96.

Canadian multiculturalism is a dishonest euphemism whose true meaning is cultural relativism, clientelism and a bigotry of low expectations, treating minorities as static, well circumscribed and distinct from the majority. It represents the death of universalism and a return to tribalism. A prime example of the consequences of multiculturalism is the experience of Yasmine Mohammed who, after suffering much abuse as a teenager at the hands of her pious Muslim step-father, was abandoned by Canadian authorities, both police and judge, who refused to take action because “different cultures are free to discipline their children in different ways.” Other consequences include all sorts of so-called “reasonable accommodations” (which should instead be called “unreasonable religious accommodations”) such as depriving children of music because of their parents’ religion, allowing—even celebrating—the veiling of young girls, thus endorsing a form of child abuse, allowing civil servants to wear religious symbols while on duty (which Bill 21 bans in Quebec) and so on.

The Québécois oppose Canadian multiculturalism because it reduces them to just another minority, which leads inexorably to Anglo-supremacy. Under Canadian multiculturalism, every language is reduced to folklore status, except English of course. Bravo Quebec for standing up for cultural and linguistic diversity!

Canadian multiculturalism is incompatible with secularism, because secularism requires that all citizens be treated equally, regardless of their religious affiliation or lack thereof. Neither Christians, nor atheists, nor Muslims, nor any other specific group should be allowed to display their personal religious opinions or identity while working in the civil service. This is called universalism and it is a core value of secularism. Those Anglo-Canadians who claim to be secularists need to face that reality.

Multiculturalism is the Great Canadian Euphemism. Proponents of this retrograde ideology arrogate to themselves the moral high ground, as if anyone who criticizes it were morally stunted or even “racist.” Their hypocrisy is obvious. Not only is multiculturalism a throwback to tribal days before the advent of universal human rights, it is also a tool used by anti-secularists to rationalize their anti-QuĂ©bĂ©cois ethnic bigotry.

On this 24th of June 2022, a holiday here in Quebec, the FĂȘte nationale, we celebrate QuĂ©bĂ©cois language and culture. (This blog is in English because Anglo-Canadians are the ones who most need to read it.) Taking steps to protect the French language in Quebec is in everyone’s interest, including English-speakers, because without it, Canada and North America would be culturally much poorer. Without French language and culture, without Quebec, would Canada be anything more than a pale replica of the USA?

Addendum

Here is another example of Canadian multiculturalism in action: No child protection for Syrian refugee punched and lashed in N.S. for texting with a boy

Authorities used confusion about the victim’s age as an excuse to do nothing. The teenage girl was the target of a severe beating, enough to break her nose apparently. Whether she was 15 or 16 at the time, her father must be held accountable. But this is Canada. Would this have been allowed if the family were not immigrants from a Muslim country?


Next blog: Flawed Constitutions

Repeal Citizenship Regulation 17.1.b

Canadian Media Continue to Promote Religious Privilege

2022-03-25

A recent article in The Toronto Star reminds us of the niqab controversy from several years ago, and how Canadian elites supported extreme right-wing political Islam at that time, as they continue to do today.

Sommaire en français Un article rĂ©cent du Toronto Star nous rappelle la polĂ©mique autour du niqab d’il y a plusieurs annĂ©es et comment les Ă©lites canadiennes ont soutenu l’islam politique d’extrĂȘme droite Ă  cette Ă©poque, comme elles continuent de le faire aujourd’hui.

Never underestimate the fatuity of Canadian mainstream media. There is no way that The Toronto Star can justify its recent publication of an asinine article by Haroon Siddiqui, under the title Will Charest and Brown force the Conservatives to confront their Islamophobia problem?. Siddiqui excoriates the Conservative Party, especially its former leader and prime minister Stephen Harper, for their so-called “Islamophobia,” in particular for Harper’s attempts to prevent the wearing of the niqab at citizenship ceremonies.

We all remember the events of 2015: the religious fanatic, Zunera Ishaq, succeeded in getting the courts to force the federal authorities to allow her to wear a niqab at her citizenship ceremony. This obscene situation, where the strictures of an extremely misogynistic and obscurantist medieval (or pre-medieval) politico-religious ideology were given precedence over common sense, was made possible by two things: (1) dubious Canadian legislation, especially article 17.1.b of the Citizenship Regulations, and (2) the scurrilous Canadian media and political elites who regularly bully anyone who may disagree with their mollycoddling of Islamism by showering them with ridiculous accusations. For example, in a Feb. 16, 2016 article in the Globe & Mail, Gerald Caplan of the NDP declared that attempts to ban the niqab constituted a “demagogic racist campaign against the niqab by Mr. Harper and associates.” The idea that there could be anything “racist” about trying to restrain the spread of political Islam is beyond moronic.

At the time, the Harper government was vilified for opposing so-called “barbaric cultural practices” but such opposition is eminently reasonable. Insisting that women wear the niqab anywhere and everywhere for religious reasons is certainly a barbaric practice, although I would not call it “cultural” but rather “anti-cultural.”

The problem with the Harper government of the day was that it did too little to try to stop Ishaq and her fanatical allies.

The problem with the Harper government of the day was that it did too little to try to stop Ishaq and her fanatical allies. Its efforts were limited to court appeals, i.e. it appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada to overturn the 2015-10-05 decision by the Federal Court of Appeal in Ishaq’s favour. The Liberal government of Justin Trudeau, elected only two week later, simply withdrew that appeal.

The Harper government could have done much more, if it had acted earlier. It could, for example, have adopted legislation to repeal article 17.1.b of the Citizenship Regulations, part of the Citizenship Act, which stipulates that the oath must be administered with “the greatest possible freedom in the religious solemnization or the solemn affirmation thereof.” That stipulation was one of the foundations on which Ishaq’s lawyers built their case.

But of course, the Conservative government would never consider repealing that article, because it would alienate their Christian base who would surely not tolerate the repeal of such an important religious privilege. Thus, Ishaq, Islamists and their anti-Enlightenment dupes were able to benefit from Christian bigotry in order to a further the agenda of political Islam.

The Conservatives favour Christianity because that is their tradition, while the Liberals and NDP favour Islam because it is the current fashion.

All three major federal political parties—Liberals, New Democrats and Conservatives—are antisecular, pro-religious and utterly lacking in intellectual integrity whenever the issue of religiour privilege raises its ugly head. The Conservatives favour Christianity because that is their tradition, while the Liberals and NDP favour Islam because it is the current fashion.

Speaking of a lack of integrity, where were all those so-called “secular” organizations in Canada outside Quebec back in 2015? Why did they not all oppose the niqab at official ceremonies as any secularist must obviously do? Allowing such a religious privilege is a clear violation of the principle of religion-State separation as well as a violation of religious neutrality. It must be emphasized that religious neutrality does not mean the State should grant privileges equally to all religions! On the contrary, it means that privileges cannot be justified for religious reasons if such privileges are not also allowed for non-religious ideologies.

If there had been a secular movement in Canada outside Quebec in 2015, that movement would have massively opposed allowing religious privileges at citizenship ceremonies. Similarly, if there were a secular movement in Canada outside Quebec today, in 2022, it would currently be fighting massively in support of Quebec Bill 21 and against the hysterical opposition to that very reasonable legislation.

A LĂ©ger Marketing poll at the time of the niqab controversy indicated that 82% of Canadians favoured banning face-coverings at citizenship ceremonies, while the percentage was even higher in Quebec. Thus, so-called “secular” organizations in English Canada are hypocrites who are less secular than the majority of ordinary Canadians.


Next blog: The Patriots of Lower Canada

English Canada’s Messiah Complex

2021-12-17

English Canada has gone completely nuts—again—in it reaction against Quebec’s secular Bill 21.

Sommaire en français Le Canada anglais est virĂ© complĂštement fou — et pas pour la premiĂšre fois — dans sa rĂ©action contre la loi laĂŻque quĂ©bĂ©coise, la Loi 21.

I never cease to be amazed by the arrogance, self-righteousness and wilful ignorance of Anglo-Canadian opponents of secularism. There is usually a huge dose of contempt for Quebeckers underneath everything they say about Bill 21, as if Quebeckers were retarded troglodytes who need to be controlled and enlightened by the intervention of their wonderfully superior English-speaking neighbours.

…as if Quebeckers were retarded troglodytes who need to be controlled and enlightened by the intervention of their wonderfully superior English-speaking neighbours.

English Canada’s hysterical reaction to Bill 21 has reached new extremes. Its Messiah complex is out of control. Now Brampton (ON) and Calgary (AB) want to fight Bill 21, as if it were any of their phoquing business. The mayor of Toronto has endorsed Brampton’s idea. Many other Canadian municipalities and provinces have made pronouncements against Bill 21 in the past. Canada’s ambassador to the UN, Bob Rae, declared recently that Bill 21 violates the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights—a bald-faced lie. Just consult article 29(2) of that declaration.

Even Mayor ValĂ©rie Plante of MontrĂ©al, a politician whom I do not particularly like, had the good sense to warn mayors of municipalities outside Quebec that they should not be using taxpayers’ money to finance a challenge to a law in a different province. Even Quebec Solidaire (QS)—notorious for having dishonestly abandoned its previous pro-secular position only shortly after the last provincial election—expressed similar misgivings.

Bill 21 is very moderate, even timid. Several European countries have similar but stronger legislation dealing with religious symbols, and many more countries ban full-face coverings (including many Muslim-majority countries). A person who refuses to remove any religious symbol while on the job, especially if working as a civil servant or teacher, is behaving unethically. To allow the wearing of such symbols by civil servants and teachers is to grant an obvious religious privilege.

The English- and French-speaking worlds have two different ways of managing religion-State relations. Much can and has been written to explain the differences, but the most important distinction can be summed up in one simple but crucial principle: Separation between religions and State. So-called secularists in the English-speaking world regularly use this term “Separation” but rarely apply it completely. But the 1905 French secularism law has that term in its very title, “Loi de sĂ©paration des Églises et de l’État)”, and the principle is applied much more consistently in France.

All secular organizations in Quebec support Bill 21, but NO so-called “secular” organization in Canada outside Quebec supports it. Think about that for a moment.

Quebec follows the French model, but has some distance to go. Bill 21 needs to be strengthened at least by (1) extending religious symbol bans to the entire civil service and all school personnel, and (2) ending fiscal privileges still granted to religious institutions. However, Quebec is far ahead of the rest of Canada. All secular organizations in Quebec support Bill 21, but NO so-called “secular” organization in Canada outside Quebec supports it. Think about that for a moment.

…they must at least recognize Quebec’s jurisdiction in this matter and stop meddling in that province’s internal affairs.

When the separation principle is included, I call this “republican secularism” in order to avoid confusion (because the word “secularism” alone may be ambiguous). The republican model is clearly superior to the Anglo-American model, but if English Canadians are too ethnocentric or pig-headed to admit this, they must at least recognize Quebec’s jurisdiction in this matter and stop meddling in that province’s internal affairs.

Canada is a federation in which provinces have a certain degree of autonomy. Bill 21 is within Quebec’s provincial jurisdiction. When people from outside Quebec intervene in an attempt to repeal a Quebec law like Bill 21, democratically adopted and supported by the majority of the population of that province, then those intervenors are practising a form of neo-colonialism and cultural imperialism. And this from a people who swear by so-called “multiculturalism” as some kind of dogma! Obviously, that prefix “multi” does not include the QuĂ©bĂ©cois.

Given a choice between republican secularism and religious privilege—including privileges for political Islam—only a fool, or a religious leader, would choose to support the latter. But that is what opponents of Bill 21 are choosing.

Their cowardly conformism to the dominant ideology of cultural relativism confuses other secularists and weakens the cause enormously.

Those organizations which claim to be secular, while hypocritically opposing secularism in the one place in Canada which is making real progress in that direction, are arguably the worst. Their cowardly conformism to the dominant ideology of cultural relativism confuses other secularists and weakens the cause enormously. The very people who should be putting their energies into supporting initiatives such as Bill 21 and making public statements to counter the hysterical anti-secularism of the Anglo-Canadian press and politicians are doing just the opposite. They have betrayed this important cause—and the many Canadians who support Bill 21—by choosing convenience over principle and religious privilege over separation.

If the current court challenge to Bill 21 reaches the Supreme Court of Canada, which is probable, and if that Court strikes the law down, which is possible, that decision will surely cause a major constitutional crisis. This in turn will, in all probability, lead to a huge increase in support for the Quebec independence movement, which eventually may lead to a unilateral declaration of independence by Quebec.

Quebec will continue its process of secularization which it started over half a century ago at the beginning of the Quiet Revolution. It can continue that progress either as a province within Canada, or as an independent secular republic.


Next blog: Bill 21 as Seen by Four Quebec Secularists

Three Examples of Cultural (Mis)Appropriation

Christianity, Islam and Canada

2019-12-03

In this blog I present three instances when a idea or a set of concepts was appropriated from an existing culture by a newly forming religious or political entity. Should we call it cultural appropriation, or cultural misappropriation?

Sommaire en français Je prĂ©sente dans ce billet de blogue trois exemples d’une idĂ©e ou d’un ensemble de concepts qu’une nouvelle entitĂ© religieuse ou politique s’est appropriĂ© Ă  partir d’une culture existante. S’agit-il d’appropriation culturelle ou de « mĂ©sappropriation Â» culturelle.

In a previous blog, I argued that the taboo against so-called “cultural appropriation” is irrational and harmful, because intercultural borrowing is not only very widespread—being practically the norm rather than the exception— and furthermore because it enriches human cultures and improves the general quality of life. I also suggested, in those rarer cases when such borrowing is harmful in some way to the orginating group and may thus be reasonably considered a sort of plagiarism or even theft, that the term “cultural misappropriation” be used instead. Of course, determining the category into which a particular case should be classified often leaves plenty of room for debate.

In this blog, I give three examples of borrowing where the resulting concept is so well known, so commonplace, that most people are probably unaware, or have forgotten, that any borrowing had occurred.

Christianity

It is well-known that Christianity is basically a rip-off of Judaism. I call it Judaism for ancient Greeks. The religion of the Hebrews, Judaism, was just another of countless tribal religions among various peoples of antiquity in and around the Roman Empire. It was not even a monotheism until rather late in its history, starting first as a polytheism, then evolving into a monolatry (worship of one god while recognizing the existence of many others) and finally emerging as a monotheism, where all gods were subsumed under their one god Jehovah. (This last step was a rationalization used by the defeated Hebrews to explain how the god of a rival tribe could defeat theirs—at least that is the explanation put forward by author Jean Soler to explain the origins of monotheism.)

Then along came Paul of Tarsus, a rather dysfunctional individual, especially his views on sexuality, whom Christians venerate as “Saint Paul.” Paul took an obscure Jewish reform movement and turned it into a new religion Christianity, and the rest is history. Paul was the founder of Christianity, not Jesus, because the existence of Jesus is uncertain, and even if he did exist, we know almost nothing about him. Christianity borrowed heavily from both Judaism (a large chunk of the Christian bible is lifted directly from the Hebrews) and from the religion of the ancient Greeks (for example, the concept of hell is an extension of Hades, but much worse). Of course Christianity also borrowed from Egyptian and other religions, in particular the concepts of virgin birth and the son of god.

Christians were persecuted for centuries by the Roman authorities, because their dogmatic monotheism was so intolerant that they refused to recognize the gods and authority of Rome. Constantine put an end to that persecution in the early IVth century C.E. and later that century the spectacularly intolerant Theodosius Ist made Nicene Christianity the empire’s state religion, while banning all other religions including the traditional cults of the Roman and Greek gods.

Thus, in creating the new religion of Christianity, a tribal religion was transformed into one with universalist pretentions and which persecuted anyone, regardless of ethnicity, who refused to adopt it. In particular, Jews who refused to convert to the new fashionable religion were particularly reviled, and the crucifixion story, an essential part of Christian mythology, was used as a convenient excuse for that persecution on the pretext that it was Jews who had murdered Jesus Christ. It is amusing to note that the word “pagan” is derived from the Latin “pāgānus” meaning “rural” or “rustic” (and related to “peasant”), as non-Christians were apparently considered country bumpkins not yet hip to the cool new religion of Christianity which was all the rage in urban centres of the empire.

Islam

Several centuries after the Christians plagiarized Judaism, along came Muhammad, calling himself a prophet of the one true god—indeed claiming to be the last prophet of god for all eternity! He borrowed heavily from Judaism and Christianity, the so-called religions of the Book, which he apparently envied for their scriptures which gave them an aura of wisdom and sagacity. His new religion Islam is sometimes considered to be a derivative of Arian Christianity. Arianism was a non-Nicene variant of Christianity (i.e. no trinity) which was rejected as heresy by the First Council of Nicaea, convoked by Constantine in 325.

I call Islam Judaism for Arabs. Muhammad initially attempted to convert some Jewish tribes, living in the Arabian peninsula, to his new religion, but when they refused, he had them massacred. Basically, Muhammad took two bad ideas, Judaism and Christianity, combined them and put himself at the centre of the result, which became arguably even more intolerant than the two already very intolerant source religions. The quran contains many expressions of anti-Jewish sentiment, as well as lots of misogyny and violent hostility towards unbelievers and polytheists.

Canada

According to the Historical Dictionary of European Imperialism by James Stuart Olson, “The name Canada probably is derived from the Huron-Iroquois kanata, meaning a village or a community.” So we can consider the use of the word Canada by Europeans to be a form of cultural appropriation, although a rather trivial one, as many languages borrow heavily from others. However, a far more significant form of cultural (mis)appropriation occurred centuries after Europeans overran the Americas.

Until the British conquest of New France in the Seven Years’ War (1756–1763), Canada was basically just another name for New France. This territory was divided by the British into Upper and Lower Canada (« les deux Canadas Â») and its inhabitants, « les Canadiens Â» or « Canayens Â», were of course mainly French-speaking and descended from settlers from France with some intermarriage with native peoples. The two Canadas were re-united by the Act of Union of 1840-1841 into a single colony known as « Canada-Uni Â» or the “Province of Canada” in an attempt by the British to assimilate francophones into the anglophone majority.

Then in 1867, year of Confederation, the two then became distinct provinces, Ontario and Québec, in the newly founded nation which we call Canada. By that time, only Quebec was majority French-speaking, because immigration into Upper Canada, a.k.a. Ontario, had made it mainly English-speaking. At Confederation, Canada was composed of four provinces (with New Brunswick and Nova Scotia), and since then six more have been added to make ten today.

The point of this brief historical review is to explain that the name “Canada” and the adjective “Canadian” refer primarily to New France and its inhabitants, but those terms have been appropriated by the country Canada founded in 1867 in which English was and remains the dominant language. That dominance increases with each passing decade, for a variety of reasons. Thus, the word “Canadian” should properly refer to the QuĂ©bĂ©cois who are the descendants of the inhabitants of New France.

Of course, that is not how things have worked out. The name “Canada” now refers to a country which stretches from the Atlantic Ocean to the Pacific and from the Arctic islands in the north to the U.S. border in the south. Those who once referred to themselves as « Canayens Â» now prefer, or at least have become habituated to, the term « QuĂ©bĂ©cois Â» and have abandoned the now quaint-sounding « Canadiens français Â». However, even after all these years, the two language groups in this enlarged Canada, English and French, are still divided by some major differences in culture and values.

So, the next time you hear some Canadian ideologue complain about how Quebecers are so stubborn and backward (or worse) and fail to worship fashionable Canadian ideals such as so-called “multiculturalism” (i.e. communitarianism) or the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, just remember that Canadians appropriated the term “Canada” and now, using that plagiarized name, wish to impose forcefully on Quebecers values they do not agree with. It must not be forgotten that the Charter is part of the 1982 Constitution which has never been approved by Quebec and was indeed foisted upon it against its will. If anyone gloats about the fact that Quebec is legally required to obey the Charter, what they are basically saying is that “Might Makes Right”—ethics and democracy be damned. This whole scenario reminds me of how Christians plagiarized Jews and polytheists, then vilified the former as Christ-killers and denigrated the latter as pagans.

Appropriation or Misappropriation?

Should the three cases explained above be considered appropriation or misappropriation? I think it is clear that the borrowing in each case ended up being rather harmful to those who were plagiarized. This is especially the case with Christianity and Islam, both of which have been, and often continue to be, very anti-Jewish. The final example, that of Canada, is much less extreme, but nevertheless harmful to the plagiarized Québécois. I consider all three examples to be cases of misappropriation. However, I do not think that any kind of corrective re-appropriation, for lack of a better expression, is in order. That would be akin to rewriting history. It would absurd to ban the use of the Pentateuch by Christians because they copied it from the Hebrews. It would be equally absurd to require that Muslims stop referring to Abraham and Jesus as (lesser) prophets of Islam. And it would be ridiculous to insist that the country we now know as Canada change its name.

Rewriting history, in the sense of erasing parts of it, is for fools and demagogues. What we do need to do is to remember history, to preserve it, to enrich our knowledge of it, to learn from it and to use it as one resource among many as we face the future. We can learn two lessons from the above historical considerations: (1) neither Christianity nor Islam had anything particularly original to offer; and (2) Canadians have no right to feel self-righteous and superior to the Québécois.


Next blog: DĂ©cision de la Cour d’appel du QuĂ©bec, 2019-12-12

Canada’s Anti-Blasphemy Law Repealed, But M-103 Remains

2018-12-13

Canada’s anti-blasphemy law has finally been repealed. Excellent news. However, Motion M-103 which condemns “Islamophobia” remains in force.
Sommaire en français La loi canadienne qui criminalise le blasphĂšme est enfin abrogĂ©e. Excellente nouvelle ! Toutfois, la Motion M-103 qui condamne l’« islamophobie Â» demeure en vigueur.
The Canadian Senate has voted to repeal the country’s “blasphemous libel” law (Section 296 of the Criminal Code), as part of a Bill C-51 which removes outdated legislation. Earlier today (2018-12-13) the senate announced on its twitter feed that the Bill has received Royal Assent and is thus adopted. This has excellent news indeed and has been reported on a number of atheist and humanist web sites such as End Blasphemy Laws and The Friendly Atheist. However, before breaking out the champagne, consider this. The various reports I have seen so far fail to mention an important problem: Motion M-103 remains on the books. That Motion condemns so-called “Islamophobia” and thus sets the stage for a new kind of anti-blasphemy legislation, condemning criticism of one religion, but without explicit use of the word “blasphemy.” Although Motion M-103 does not have force of law, it is dangerous for exactly the same reason as Section 296: its international impact. Both Section 296 and Motion M-103 give countries with similar legislation a convenient excuse to continue violating human rights by pointing to Canada’s bad example. Section 296 did not, of course, have force of law outside Canada either, and even inside Canada it had not been used for decades. Nevertheless, the symbolic effect was negative. Motion M-103 continues to provide that negative example. Furthermore, Motion M-103 is, in one sense, even worse that Section 296 in that it privileges one specific religion, giving it preferential treatment. So in addition to constituting a form of soft censorship of criticism of Islam, it will generate animosity from believers in other religions which are not so privileged. Moreover, there is a legitimate fear that in future M-103 may be followed eventually by a similar proposal, inspired by it, but having force of law.
Such accusations have precisely the same chilling effect as Motion M-103: they are a form of intimidation which stifles criticism of Islam and helps to further the agenda of political Islam.
This problem is complicated by the fact that some of the very people who applaud the repeal of Section 296 and claim to be secularists hypocritically support M-103. Even worse, some even repeat absurd accusations that to oppose M-103 is necessarily a right-wing or far-right position. Such accusations have precisely the same chilling effect as Motion M-103: they are a form of intimidation which stifles criticism of Islam and helps to further the agenda of political Islam. Secularists must now work to repeal Motion M-103 and to prevent the Canadian parliament from adopting in the future any motion or legislation similar or worse.

Next blog: Open Letter to TheConversation: An Organ of Anti-Quebec Propaganda

Ensaf Haidar Challenges Canadian Orthodoxy

Raif Badawi’s wife refuses to kowtow to the “diversity” ideologues

2018-09-22

I congratulate Ensaf Haidar for her call to ban face-coverings in public services and for her support for Maxime Bernier’s criticism of Trudeau-ite multiculturalism.

Sommaire en français Je félicite Ensaf Haidar pour son appel à interdire les couvre-visage dans les services publics et pour son appui à Maxime Bernier qui critique le multiculturalisme à la Trudeau.

As most people are already aware, Ensaf Haidar is the wife of Raif Badawi, a Saudi writer, dissident and activist who has been imprisoned since 2012 in Saudi Arabia. His only “crime” was to call for a liberalisation of the Saudi regime.

Ensaf Haidar now lives with her children in Quebec and all received Canadian citizenship on July 1st 2018. Haidar has worked tirelessly for her husband’s release and for human rights in general, and has received several awards for her efforts. Two recent examples are the 2017 Goldene Victoria, awarded by the Verband Deutscher Zeitschriftenverleger (Association of German Magazine Publishers), and the 2018 Henry Zumach Freedom From Fundamentalist Religion Award from the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF).

2018 Henry Zumach Freedom From Fundamentalist Religion Award
Ensaf Haidar: 2018 Recipient Henry Zumach Freedom From Fundamentalist Religion Award

Just as her husband defied Saudi orthodoxy by calling for freedom of expression, Ensaf Haidar challenges Canadian orthodoxy […]

Just as her husband defied Saudi orthodoxy by calling for freedom of expression, Ensaf Haidar challenges Canadian orthodoxy by exercising her freedom of expression in defiance of the conventional ideology monolithically imposed by most Canadian mainstream media and politicians, especially the federal government of Justin Trudeau. On her Twitter account @miss9afi, she has repeatedly urged the new Premier of Ontario to follow Quebec’s lead and ban the niqab in Ontario schools, public transportation and government services.

2018-09-16, Tweet, Ensaf Haidar
“I urge Ontario PM to follow Quebec’s and outlaw the Niqab
from schools, public transportation & all govt services”

Unfortunately the comparison with Quebec no longer applies, because article 10 of Quebec’s Bill 62, which banned face-coverings in public services, has been suspended by the courts and the Quebec government has failed to make any effort to fight back against the suspension.

Furthermore, Ensaf Haidar has expressed her support for Maxime Bernier’s criticism of Trudeau’s dubious cult of “diversity,” despite the fact that Bernier has been the target of an enormous degree of contempt and demonisation from the media for a position which is, in reality, eminently reasonable. Tarek Fatah writes about this in his article of September 18th, Why Raif Badawi’s wife supports Maxime Bernier in the Toronto Sun. Haidar expressed her shock at the negative reaction to Bernier and his new political party (People’s Party of Canada or PPC) in a tweet on September 18th.

2018-09-20, Tweet, Ensaf Haidar
“I am shocked at the reaction to my support of the #PPC and @MaximeBernier,
I will listen to myself and look for the new change”

Trudeau’s “diversity” is simply […] a buzzword which he uses to set the stage for spurious accusations of racism or xenophobia against anyone who criticizes his pandering to religious minorities.

I do not support Bernier’s new party—its economic policies are those of the libertarian right—but I agree with his and Haidar’s criticism of Trudeau’s obsession with what Bernier calls “extreme multiculturalism.” Indeed, Trudeau’s multiculturalism is cultural relativism, leading to complacency and inaction in the face of religious fanaticism. Trudeau’s “diversity” is simply code expressing his extreme intolerance of any disagreement with his ideology, a buzzword which he uses to set the stage for spurious accusations of racism or xenophobia against anyone who criticizes his pandering to religious minorities.

I congratulate Ensaf Haidar for her principled support for Bernier’s criticisms and for her opposition to the Trudeau-ite obsession of allowing religious face-coverings anywhere and everywhere.


More Relevant Links


Next blog: The Quebec Election of October 1st 2018

Exploiting Mass Murder for Political Gain

2017-02-17

I recently learned that I am the target of defamatory remarks published on a Canadian web site. I am accused of a certain degree of complicity in the Quebec City murders. This is my response.

Sommaire en français Je viens d’apprendre que je suis la cible de propos diffamatoires publiĂ©s sur un site web canadien. On m’accuse d’un certain degrĂ© de complicitĂ© dans la rĂ©cente tuerie Ă  QuĂ©bec. Voici ma rĂ©ponse.

In a recent blog The Quebec City Attack: Some Context, I wrote:

It took a very short time for the unscrupulous to begin exploiting this tragedy for political ends. Slanderous and hateful comments have been made, …

When I wrote the above, I did not yet realize how appallingly true it would turn out to be. It has recently come to my attention that I have been accused, on a certain Canadian web site, of a certain degree of complicity in the Quebec City massacre, although it is a little vague (perhaps deliberately so) what that degree is. What was the nature of my complicity in this atrocity? According to my accuser, my criticism of the word “islamophobia” in a recent blog Fools Against “Islamophobia” implies a total—and, in my accuser’s apparent estimation, near-criminal—disregard for anti-Muslim prejudice.

In that blog I criticized gay activists in Ontario and in the U.K. for their inappropriate response to the Orlando shooting in which about 50 were massacred in a gay bar. Instead of concentrating their energies on denouncing religious homophobia, in this case Islamic homophobia, they foolishly chose to demonstrate against “Islamophobia” as if “the possibility of antipathy towards those who practice Islam is worse than murdering gays in the name of Islam.” Furthermore, they chose incorrect language to do so: if they were concerned about the danger of an anti-Muslim backlash, i.e. attacks against real people, they could have denounced anti-Muslim prejudice.

But instead, these gay activists used the term “Islamophobia” which implies a (possibly irrational) fear of the ideology Islam. This is wrong for at least two reasons: (1) there is nothing irrational about fearing Islam; and (2) criticizing an ideology is very different from hatred of real human beings. By confusing the two issues, these activists stigmatized criticism of Islam and its cousin Islamism, thus playing into the hands of Islamist propagandists. Those who control language also control minds. The words we choose are important. Clarity is essential.

…the Quebec City killing of six Muslims was far, far worse than mere “Islamophobia.” It was not an attack on a religion or an idea. On the contrary, it was murderous violence against living, breathing human beings.

What is ironic here is that the Quebec City killing of six Muslims was far, far worse than mere “Islamophobia.” It was not an attack on a religion or an idea. On the contrary, it was murderous violence against living, breathing human beings. It was anti-Muslim terrorism, it was an anti-Muslim massacre. (Some people reject the term “terrorism” in this case. I tend to disagree.) We all have a duty, especially atheists and secularists, to distinguish between ideas and people, i.e. between beliefs and believers. To confuse the two categories only increases the danger of misunderstandings and possibly retribution for past acts of violence.

I also know why my accuser hates me (although we do not even know each other). Based on previous writings, it is clear that my criticism of communitarianism, a.k.a. multiculturalism, and my concomitant support for republican secularism burn his or her butt.

It is not clear whether my accuser is literally insane, or merely a horrific jerk. Maybe both? Fortunately, unlike Donald Trump, my accuser is not the head of a powerful nation with massive nuclear capability, so there is a limit to how much damage the lout can do. Unfortunately he or she is far from alone in this venal practice of exploiting a bloody tragedy for partisan political purposes.

Yesterday I slipped on some ice, fell and hurt my knee. Who or what is to blame? I blame Islamophobia and the Quebec “Charter of Values.” … OK, just kidding.

It has been said (I am unable to locate the source) that the only vice is conformism. Since the Quebec City attack on January 29th, we have seen a lot of vicious conformism. There has been a chorus of unscrupulous individuals claiming that the debate, in 2013-2014, around the Charter of Secularism proposed by the previous Quebec government, was a major cause of the massacre. This is accompanied by lamenting the prevalence of “identity politics” or “nationalisme identitaire” etc., etc. when in reality the Charter would have imposed neutrality on public institutions so that individuals would be prevented from promoting their particular, partisan religious or political identity while being paid from public funds. The Charter would have attenuated identity politics.

One very high profile example of this is the recent media splash by Charles Taylor who was co-president of the Bouchard-Taylor Commission, about a decade ago. The Commission was mandated to study the issue of so-called “reasonable accommodation” which to be precise should be called religious accommodation. One of its principal recommendations was that public servants in positions of coercive authority—police, judges, etc.—should not be allowed to wear religious symbols while on duty. I think such symbols should be banned for all public servants while on duty, but the Commission’s recommendation was at least a step in the right direction.

Taylor has exploited the Quebec City massacre as an excuse to repudiate, in a very public fashion, one of the rare constructive positions he has taken in the past.

Very recently, Taylor repudiated his previous position; he now thinks that no such ban should be imposed. His reason? The Quebec City event has changed the situation and, according to Taylor, the debate over the Quebec Charter “stigmatized” some groups. In reality, as ex-MNA Fatima Houda-Pepin has revealed, Taylor has discreetly held his current opinion for years, since long before the recent event. In other words, Taylor has exploited the Quebec City massacre as an excuse to repudiate, in a very public fashion, one of the rare constructive positions he had taken in the past.

But the prize for the most excessive and most egregious behaviour exploiting the Quebec City tragedy goes to Member of Parliament Iqra Khalid who is promoting her motion M-103 condemning “Islamophobia.” According to a CBC news report, she defines that term as “the irrational hate of Muslims that leads to discrimination.” Once again, we see a deliberate confusion of terms in order to justify a dangerous threat to freedom of expression. And once again, both the political centre and the so-called left have completely abandoned all rationality, so that only some members of the Conservative Party oppose the motion, thus allowing its promoters to accuse anyone who disagrees with them of being right-wingers.

My accuser is a petty member of that rogue’s gallery of unprincipled conformists.

You are allowed to disagree with me. But you are not allowed to accuse me of complicity in murder.

Further reading:


Next blog: Islam and Islamism