2022-10-20
No, the “woke” phenomenon is not some moral panic invented by the political right.
Sommaire en français Non, la mouvance « woke » n’est pas une panique morale inventée par la droite. Ce blogue est disponible en français sous le titre Le « wokisme » n’est pas une panique morale.
For several years, terms such as “Social Justice Warrior” (“SJW”) and “woke” were used by many members of that movement themselves, to self-identify. Over time, the word “woke” became mainstream and, as critics of “wokism” began to use it negatively, the word acquired pejorative connotations. (It is important to note that these critics are of all political persuasions, from Marxists to the political centre to people on the right.)
Now some people even claim that “wokism” does not exist, that it is just a right-wing fantasy, a “moral panic” invented by the political right to denigrate the left. That allegation is false and dishonest. The “woke” themselves adopted the word long before anyone else. Not only is “wokism” a real phenomenon but, most importantly, it is ideologically distinct from the classical political left.
So what is “wokism” anyway? It is a social movement that claims to be left-wing and prides itself on fighting for social justice and against various prejudices, especially racism. But the philosophical underpinnings of the “woke” phenomenon are strongly influenced by postmodernism and by the rejection of Enlightenment values, in particular the rejection of universalism. Its rejection of the Enlightenment represents the abandonment of the greatest achievement of European civilization.
Consequently, this movement does a very bad job of defending the minorities with which it is obsessed. The “woke” end up inflaming racism as much as fighting against it. To put it succinctly, the movement is neo-racist. I call it the post-left or the anti-Enlightenment pseudo-left.
The “woke” have the nasty habit of launching accusations of “fascism” against anyone who disagrees with them. This is very ironic—and hypocritical—because the “woke” and the far right have something very significant in common: they both reject Enlightenment values.
The excesses and follies of the “woke” are a real gift for the political right, because the latter uses them to denigrate the entire left, as if the being “woke” were synonymous with being on the political left. But this is false, because the real left is universalist.
For a more detailed presentation of “wokism,” see:
- My blog The “Woke” are Not the Political Left, A movement which abandons Enlightenment values is no longer progressive.
- Le volume Identité, « race », liberté d’expression (“Identity, ‘Race’ and Freedom of Expression”), collective work available from Presses de l’Université Laval.
Other Links
- Le wokisme, ce recul déguisé en progrès (“Wokism, this regress disguised as progress”), Marc Simard, Libre Média, 2022-10-08.
“In fact, interbreeding is a threat to wokism, whose worldview is deeply rooted in racial affiliation. Racial mixing is the nemesis of the woke.” - The Cancer of Wokeism, Kareem Muhssin, Alliance of Former Muslims (Ireland), 2021-01-02.
“If we want to defeat racism, then we must get over our obsession with race. We must stop seeing each other as victims or oppressors, and recognise that we are individuals with agency. We must stop looking for racism where it doesn’t exist, and start focusing on issues of substance.”
Next blog: Pauline Marois : Prix international de la laïcité 2022
Traditionally, yeah the left stemmed from the enlightenment era and its core values, that are universal: liberty, equality and justice.
One must understand from where the enlightenment era came from: millenium of the traditional “Indo-European” tripartite way of organizing society. Which was a caste society (like in India), where both religious and military institutions were sharing power while the “productive” society didn’t have much leverage = feodalism.
But after the “revolution era” that came post enlightenment, where the authority and privileges of the aristocratic class was taken from them, and they were blamed as a group for all of humanity’s problem (psychologically speaking = scapegoating/projection), problems began to emerge that were challenging the “enlightenment rhetoric” = a new power system emerged, where aristocrats were replaced by a dominant “bourgeois” class (merchants, financial moguls, etc..). So the left had to find new “culprits” to “scapegoat for all of humanity’s problems” = the bourgeois class was the new ennemi and Karl Marx was the new pope of the left “dogma”…
Marx came in with his typical “manichean” way of seeing the world, where the dominants (bourgeois) where the “wicked” and the working class the “virtuous”. Its basically an over simplification of social interactions, where “competition” is deemed as inherently bad and “cooperation” as inherently good. Its the values of the “enlightenment era”, but put to the extreme, losing its “universality” in the process. Because at the end of the day, how can you have universality when the ideology has to identify a group as “the source of all evil” and the other as “inherently good and virtuous”? As manichean ways of presenting the world will ALWAYS end up in division and conflict.
And now, all those “victims as an identity” ideologies and their “university field of studies” have all adopted the marxist “manichean grid of analysis”.
Typically:
Men = the wicked
Women = the virtuous
The white european and their offsprings = the wicked
The “colored colonized” = the virtuous
The heterosexual and CIS genders = the wicked
All the rest = the virtuous
Its like a bad American movie, nuances are optional and they don’t take the option unless it serves their ideology.
Furthermore they took control of the whole left spectrum narrative, imposing it to the whole society, and imposing social norms based on that narrative/ideology. They basically one up between them for the medal of the “most legitimate victim” = because its give them a virtuous image + political privileges that comes with the “victim ” label”.
We’re actually testing the limits of the enlightenment era values, which are liberty, equality and justice. As nothing is inherently good or bad, problems arise when equilibrium is broken and concepts/principles are pushed to the limits…