Supreme Court Must Respect Quebec’s Democratic Choice of Bill 21

par Romain Gagnon (Vice President of Sceptiques du Québec), with:
David Rand (President of Atheist Freethinkers),
Daniel Baril (President of Mouvement laïque québécois),
Francois Dugré (Board member of Rassemblement pour la laïcité),
Éric Ouellet (Board member of Droits collectifs Québec),
Michel Virard (President of Association humaniste du Québec),
Andréa Richard (lauréat du Prix Condorcet-Dessaulles)

2026-03-23

When judges, police officers, prosecutors, or teachers exercise authority, they embody the public institution. The appearance of impartiality is an essential precondition for public trust. This is precisely what Bill 21 seeks to preserve.
This is an English translation of an article published (2026-03-15) in Le Devoir under the title La loi 21, un choix démocratique que la Cour suprême devrait respecter.

Sommaire en français Lorsque des juges, policiers, procureurs ou enseignants exercent une autorité, ils incarnent l’institution publique. L’apparence d’impartialité constitue un élément essentiel de la confiance du public. C’est précisément ce que cherche à préserver la loi 21.

Over five days in late March, the Supreme Court of Canada will hear arguments concerning the constitutionality of Quebec’s Act respecting the laicity of the State or Bill 21. More than fifty interveners—a record number for the Court—have been allowed to participate in this case, which involves one of the most controversial subjects in Quebec society: State secularism. Tellingly, the vast majority of those interveners oppose the Bill, despite the fact that it enjoys very broad support in Quebec.

Behind this legal battle, however, lies a more fundamental question: how can a pluralistic society genuinely protect the freedom of conscience of all?

The debate is often presented as one of religious freedom versus State neutrality. This way of framing the issue is misleading. Secularism does not aim to restrict freedom of religion; it aims to ensure freedom of conscience, which is a necessary condition for freedom of religion.

Freedom of conscience means that everyone is free to believe, not to believe, or to change their beliefs. This freedom can fully exist only if the State itself remains neutral with respect to religions. When judges, police officers, prosecutors, or teachers exercise authority, they embody the public institution. In this context, the appearance of impartiality is an essential precondition for public trust.

This is precisely what Bill 21 seeks to preserve. Bill 21 does not threaten religious faith or practice in the private sphere. It merely regulates the exercise of certain functions of authority so that the State is not perceived as endorsing a particular belief.

The history of Quebec sheds light on this choice. For a long time, the confusion between religion and power weighed heavily on public institutions. The Quiet Revolution constituted a significant break: the separation of Church and State, a prerequisite for a freer and more egalitarian public sphere.

One crucial question is often missing from this debate: can a conscience be truly free when it has been shaped from childhood by a belief system that does not tolerate being questioned? Secularism does not claim to resolve spiritual questions; rather, it creates a common framework within which everyone can believe, doubt, or break free from tradition without institutional pressure. In this sense, it protects believers as much as non-believers.

Another voice also deserves to be heard, that of the many women from Muslim backgrounds who have chosen to immigrate to Quebec. Several have publicly explained that they came here not only for economic reasons, but also to live in a society where individual choices—particularly those related to lifestyle, appearance or gender relations—are not dictated by religious norms. Some explain that they removed the veil upon arrival, after having worn it under duress in their country of origin. Their testimonies remind us that secularism cannot be reduced to a mere conflict between tolerance and discrimination. For some women, it is also about emancipation.

The debate surrounding Bill 21 also reveals a deeper divergence between two conceptions of pluralism. In English Canada, multiculturalism has become the dominant principle for managing cultural and religious diversity. This approach does not rely on a strict separation between religion and State; rather, it grants priority to accommodating public expressions of religious identities.

However, the experience of several European countries shows that this model can generate tensions when it fragments the public sphere into distinct communities. Quebec has instead chosen a different path, inspired in part by the French republican model: that of a more pronounced neutrality of public institutions. This approach enjoys very broad support in Quebec, well beyond partisan divides.

If other provinces prefer to maintain the multicultural model, they are free to do so. Quebec is not trying to impose its model on the rest of the country. It asks only that its choice be respected.

The National Assembly adopted Bill 21 and the government invoked the notwithstanding clause so that the Bill could come into effect immediately. This clause, included in the Canadian Charter, allows legislators to exercise a constitutional power explicitly, temporarily asserting parliamentary priority for a democratic choice when fundamental issues affecting the organization of society are at stake.

However, several opponents specifically want to neutralize, or even abolish, this legal instrument. This would amount to depriving Quebec of an essential means of defending its democratic choices.

The issue therefore is not simply legal. It concerns the balance between the protection of individual rights by the courts and the capacity of a democratic society to collectively define certain fundamental rules. To what extent should the courts hold the power to invalidate political choices clearly expressed by a democratic majority?

The Supreme Court justices are obviously not mandated to engage in politics. But they cannot ignore the fact that their decision risks having political repercussions far beyond the current legal debate. If a law supported by a large majority of the Quebec population were struck down by the courts, many would see it as a significant limitation on Quebec’s ability to define for itself the principles that govern its public sphere.


Next blog: CFIC Fights to Maintain Religious Privilege

One thought on “Supreme Court Must Respect Quebec’s Democratic Choice of Bill 21”

  1. I hope that everyone are ready for the hatred propaganda of the opponent of Bill 21. A mini Donald Trump is already throw in the debate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *